External Affairs
News and debates surrounding the liberalisation of the Indian legal services sector has been doing the rounds for quite some time now. Certain sections of the Indian legal fraternity (read the Bar Council) are opposed to the idea of allowing foreign law firms in India.The recent writ petition filed by A.K.Balaji raises many issues relating to what the foreign law firms can and cannot do in India under the prevailing Indian laws.
In this background, it is interesting to see that the foreign law firms have in the last few years become very active in sponsoring legal events and competitions in India. It is not new to see foreign law firms sponsoring and participating in legal conferences, however, English law firms such as Herbert Smith and Clifford Chance have taken their participation to the next level.
Earlier this year, Herbert Smith sponsored an essay writing competition in collaboration with the National Law School of India University, Bangalore,a premier law school in India. Herbert Smith has also collaborated with the National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata to organise and sponsor the NUJS-Herbert Smith National Moot Court Competition which was held for the first time in 2008. The competition this year was held between February 19 – 21, 2010 and was won by the students of NALSAR, Hyderabad. These initiatives by Herbert Smith are a part of its “Indian University Support Initiative”, which was launched in 2008. Clifford Chance has also joined the bandwagon and is sponsoring the Third National Law School International Arbitration Moot Court Competition organised by the National Law School of India University, Bangalore.
The foreign firms have also found other ways of contributing to legal education in India. For instance, representatives of Herbert Smith, Clifford Chance, Covington & Burling and several others have in the last few years, visited the campuses of the premiere law schools of India and shared their knowledge and know-how with the students by conducting short courses.
Linklaters, the blue chip English law firm has found its own way to contribute to the Indian community; it has provided financial support to the India School Fund, an innovative non-profit organisation founded by Harvard Business School graduates.The financial support provided by Linklaters has gone towards setting up of a new school in a village near Delhi.
Why such initiatives in India? Is it because the foreign law firms suddenly have new found love towards India, Indian legal community, especially students? Well, it is a settled debate that most of these firms look at India as a ‘gold mine’ of opportunities for expanding their businesses and therefore invest time, money and resource on the Indian market. I tried speaking to several law firm partners connected with these sponsorpship activities. None of them wanted to comment on their firms' practice. However, one partner of a magic circle firm commented on condition of anonymity. She said “ India for us is not a short term plan, but a long term and when I mean long term it’s a 40-50 year plan and therefore we are just letting the students (who would be potential associates and partners at the firm) and the clients know that we are world class firms who are looking at India” she said.
Over the last five years, the foreign law firms hiring from Indian law schools has increased tremendously. Linklaters alone has about 25 to 30 students from the National Law Universities. By sponsoring law school related events or conferences, these firms make themselves visible to the vast talent pool available in India.
While the debate about what the foreign firms can and cannot do so far as legal services are concerned is debatable under the prevailing laws, what is clear is that the foreign firms are in this game for the long run and therefore will continue to invest in Indian initiatives because for them the game has just begun.
|
- 1. "NUJS and NLSIU are the clear front runners when it comes to foreign recruitments. Also it is interesting to note that a leading foreign firm has an essay competition in which only students of NLSIU, NUJS, NALSAR and NLU, Jodhpur can participate!". Sachin, Goa
- 2. "Its interesting to note that The Sponsor for the Moot as well as the essay have not been able to pay the winning amounts till now!". Anon, Anon
- 3. "Come one Moily, let the foreign law firms in!!". Guest, India
- 4. "Things look positive but it will take some time before foreign law firms come in. It is obvious Indian firms will ask for equal oppurtunity to open firms abroad. There is huge interest in Indian talent but why not equal oppurtunity.". Rakesh Khanna, New Delhi
Related Stories
- Foreign law firms in India? Not yet
- Bilateral Talks between India and UK on co-operation and reforms in legal sector: Law Minister indicates early decision on entry of foreign law firms
- Conversation with Justice S. B. Sinha: “How long we can resist foreign law firms from entering India; soon they are going to enter our country with a lot of money!”
- 14-year epic battle draws to a close as Bombay High court rules against liaison offices for foreign firms
- RSG launches India Centre; releases report, ranks law firms
- Writ Petition filed against 31 foreign law firms and an LPO – Immigration law violations also alleged
- Foreign Law Firms case heats up: Women Lawyers Association and TN Advocates Association join; more foreign firms to be added to the list
Other Features
- The Viewpoint - Market Structure and Competitive Bidding
- The Viewpoint - Put/Call options: Do we have an option?
- The Viewpoint - Competing for Idle Capacity: How Coal Supply issues are Derailing Thermal Power Projects in India
- The Viewpoint - Evolution and Pattern of a Facility Agreement: Some Thoughts
- The Viewpoint - Indian Companies: Options for Raising Equity Capital Part II: Options for Listed Companies
- Just like you and me
- The Viewpoint - Rethinking Insolvency In Times of Financial Crisis
Top News
- Significant amendments proposed to Consumer Protection Act; Online filing to be made permissible, fines for non-compliance enhanced
- ALMT Legal gets four new partners; Total partner strength increases to 18
- Clasis Law gets third new partner in as many months; Maritime law expert Harsh Pratap roped in to head Shipping practice
- Foreign Law Firms Case: Arguments concluded; Judgment reserved
- Conversation with Kartikeya Tanna: “What Vineet Narain and Justice Singhvi have done, Justice Ganguly has undone”
- NALSAR hit by another scandal; Committee finds NALSAR authorities guilty of gross abuse of power (Updated)
- AIBE Update: Results withheld due to Cal High Court injunction; BCI to approach Supreme Court










