The Bombay High Court recently ordered the release of an accused after finding that a magistrate had erroneously remanded him to custody for failing to attend trial proceedings while he was already in jail in another case [Hitesh Chhotalal Solanki v. State of Maharashtra]
A Division Bench of Justices Sarang V Kotwal and Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale on November 19 set aside the non-bailable warrants issued against accused Hitesh Chhotalal Solanki on July 07 and the remand order passed on July 15 by the Judicial Magistrate First Class (JMFC), Vikhroli.
“The petitioner remains in custody though he is granted bail in both these offences. This situation needs to be corrected. The petitioner deserves to be released from custody,” the Court said.
Solanki is facing five criminal cases across Maharashtra. At present, he has secured bail in all these cases. However, two of these cases – registered at Alandi and Pant Nagar police stations – prolonged his custody.
A Sessions Court had granted him bail on May 4 in a Pant Nagar police station case. However, he continued to remain in Thane Central Prison as he was still awaiting bail in the Alandi police station case.
When the Pant Nagar case came up for hearing on July 07, Solanki could not appear because of his custody in the Alandi matter. On account of his absence, the Magistrate issued an NBW.
Though the judge was informed about his judicial custody in the Alandi case, Solanki was still remanded to magisterial custody.
The High Court criticized this judicial oversight and observed that the magistrate had erred in issuing the NBW against Solanki though he was in custody in some other case.
“ Learned JMFC was not right in ignoring the earlier bail order granted in favour of the Petitioner in connection with C.R. No.1234 of 2025 of Pant Nagar Police Station. Learned JMFC further erred in issuing NBW against the Petitioner though he was in custody in some other case and he could not remain present before the Court. Learned JMFC also erred in granting Magisterial Custody remand to the Petitioner in connection with C.R. No.1234 of 2025,” the Bench said.
The Court thus set aside the order passed by the JMFC and directed Solanki’s forthwith release.
Advocates Sahil Tejwani, Aditya Navpute, and Gaurav Tejwani represented Solanki.
Additional public prosecutor MM Deshmukh appeared for the State.
[Read order]