Mumbai Pollution 
News

Bombay High Court raps BMC, State over selective clean-up in city for VIP visits

The Court questioned why Mumbai ‘shines’ only during high-profile visits like that of British royals. It batted for an aggressive plastic ban in Mumbai, observing that this may be the only way forward to save the planet.

Neha Joshi

The Bombay High Court on Wednesday pulled up the Maharashtra government and the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) for undertaking cosmetic clean-up drives in the State only during the visits of high-profile dignitaries instead of holistically tackling the issue of pollution [Kannamwar Nagar Co-op. Housing Society v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.].

Justices GS Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale urged authorities to ensure a ‘permanent show’ of cleanliness across all city wards for ordinary citizens rather than a ‘temporary show’ of two days.

The judges pointed out that civic and State authorities had transformed areas like Ballard Estate in south Mumbai, where Britain's Prince William and Princess Katherine recently visited.

This showed that the administration was capable of acting swiftly when it chose to, the Court pointed out.

“We just observe, when some guests were coming, see Ballard Estate now, how shining and polished it is. If you want to do it, you do it, including painting, cleaning the streets with water... Do it for citizens. So instead of having this temporary show of two days, have a permanent show. Please have a permanent show in every possible ward. That is the message we want to give you," the Bench said.

Justices GS Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale
You (authorities) are going to be alive only when important personalities visit the city? You have to act for the common man who is the permanent resident of this city.
Bombay High Court

Without naming the visiting dignitaries, the Bench orally remarked,

“If the State government, BMC has a will to do, they can transform things in no time. And this we have learned through experience. It can happen with lightning speed. So, for all these important issues, you are going to be alive only when important personalities visit the city? It may not be appropriate. You have to act for the common man who is the permanent resident of this city."

The Court was hearing a plea concerning waste disposal at a landfill in the suburban area of Mumbai. They concluded that the issue at the landfill seemed to be intricately connected with the dumping of garbage on Mumbai's streets and beaches.

During the hearing, the Court also batted for “an aggressive step to ban plastic in totality" in Mumbai without succumbing to commercial interests. They concluded that it may be the only way forward to save the city and the planet.

The judges, who personally visited the dumping ground on November 17 flagged the mountains of garbage mixed with plastic at the site. 

They expressed surprise that plastic continues to be used despite persistent challenges to treating municipal waste.

The Bench questioned why BMC could not enforce a complete ban in Mumbai. 

"This is the problem of the city. Why, in so far as Mumbai is concerned, not take an aggressive step, not to succumb to any other commercial interests, but to ban in totality plastic? That would be the only way forward so that we save the planet, we save this city," the Bench told BMC’s counsel. 

The Court stressed the need to curb non-biodegradable waste at the source. It highlighted how the issue exacerbated every monsoon when the sea threw back dumped plastic onto the coastline, alongside the day-to-day crises at city dumping grounds.

The Bench directed the State government to clarify its existing policy on plastic and if other States or Union Territories have implemented a total ban. 

The Court also asked if similar prohibitions are enforced at hill stations in Maharashtra such as Matheran and Mahabaleshwar.

The next hearing on the matter will be on December 7. 

Biplab Bag joins Godfrey Philips India as Head - Legal

Bhavya Mohan rejoins AZB & Partners as Partner in Disputes practice

Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, Trilegal, Linklaters act on Bajaj Finance ₹11,700 crore QIP

AZB, Hogan Lovells, CAM, Linklaters act on Aegis Logistics ₹3,500 crore QIP

Trilegal advises SBI Funds International on launch of Signature CIO Funds from GIFT City

SCROLL FOR NEXT