Calcutta High Court 
News

Calcutta High Court refuses to grant interim protection to Abhishek Banerjee's aide Sumit Roy in repeated criminal cases

Roy has claimed that he was being targeted with false cases filed at the BJP's behest. The Court today expressed that it was not inclined to delve into these allegations for the present.

Ekoparna Datta Ray

The Calcutta High Court on Thursday refused to grant interim protection to Abhishek Banerjee's aide Sumit Roy on plea alleging that he was being targeted with multiple false criminal cases that were registered at the behest of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) [Sumit Roy v. State of West Bengal and Ors.].

Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya rejected Roy’s prayer for interim protection against coercive steps in existing or future criminal proceedings, observing that the writ court's interference was unwarranted at this stage.

During the hearing, Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayan appeared for Roy and pointed out that he was already behind bars in one of several cases filed against him.

Sankaranarayanan urged the Court to grant Roy interim protection from coercive action in the remaining cases so that he can pursue his legal remedies.

"Five FIRs are the subject matter of this petition. From those five, he is in custody in one of them. We are seeking protection with regard to the other four," Sankaranarayan submitted.

Justice Bhattacharyya, however, questioned the use of such an interim order while Roy remained incarcerated.

"That will not serve the purpose. Even if interim protection is given, he will not be able to go out of custody," the judge remarked.

Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya

The High Court proceeded to express that it was not inclined to delve into the merits of Roy's allegations for the present, while pointing out that he also alternative remedies for Roy to avail.

"The jurisdiction of the writ court in criminal matters is to be exercised sparingly when an alternative forum for remedy is already present," Justice Bhattacharyya held.

Additional Advocate General Rajdeep Mazumder appeared for the State of West Bengal.

In his plea filed under Article 226 of the Constitution, Roy has alleged that he is being subjected to a concerted campaign of political persecution following the May 4, 2026, Assembly election results, in which the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) assumed power in West Bengal.

The petition challenges five FIRs registered between July and August 2026 at the Diamond Harbour and Jibantala police stations including four lodged by BJP leader Abhijit Das @ Bobby and his associates.

The cases include those with allegations that Roy was involved in running illegal "Sebashray" medical camps using unlicensed diagnostic machines, facilitating fake educational certificates, organised crime, a 2018 armed political assault, and a 2020 attack over cyclone relief funds.

Relying on State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, Roy contended that the complaints suffer from unexplained delays of up to ten years and amount to "fishing and roving" inquiries devoid of specific overt acts.

[Read Live Coverage]

ECI has only limited powers against BLAs who file false Form 7 to delete voters: Supreme Court

Delhi High Court seeks response from ED, SFIO on plea by Tina Ambani to disclose look out circular

US court seeks help from Delhi courts to serve summons on Ajit Doval, ex-RAW chief in Gurpatwant Pannun's case

Supreme Court questions homebuyers approaching it directly over builder disputes

Madhya Pradesh High Court slams State for citing fictitious case law generated by AI tool

SCROLL FOR NEXT