The Punjab government on Thursday defended its decision to make voter identity cards mandatory for grant of benefits under the Mukh Mantri Mawan Dheeyan Satkar Yojana, a financial assistance scheme to provide monthly income support to women [Harbakhsh Charitable Society v State of Punjab & Others]
Senior Advocate Vikas Singh, representing the State government, told a Bench of Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor that other State governments also require the beneficiaries to submit their voter ID cards for verification.
In particular, he referred to the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government's Lakshmi Yojana scheme for women in Delhi. Singh's submission was cut short by the Court.
"Mr. Singh, whether it is this government, that government, this State, that State, we are not on that. We are on a simple issue. What is the justification? What is the requirement," Chief Justice Mishra said.
Singh responded that voter IDs establish that a person is actually a resident of the area and a citizen of the country.
He said the entire Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has been undertaken by the Election Commission of India (ECI) to weed out people not residing in a particular area. He said that if the Court wants further justification, the State would have to explain in detail how voter IDs are made.
"If your lordships want to get into that justification, I will have to justify how the voter ID is made in the SIR exercise. Supposing your lordships take the view that this SIR exercise is absolutely bad, illegal...," Singh added.
At this, Chief Justice asked Singh not to "drag" the Court "into areas" not related to the case. Singh said voter ID is the only document to show a person is a genuine resident of a particular area.
The Court asked Singh to refer to the law in this regard. Singh said he would like to explain the entire exercise by which voter IDs are prepared. He added that the State would file a better affidavit as in its earlier reply, it had only referred to the practice of other States.
However, the Court said there has to be some justification. Singh agreed stating that the State has to have its own logic.
"You come out with a proper stand and we will examine," the Court said, while adjourning the matter to December 15.
We are on a simple issue. What is the justification? What is the requirement?Punjab and Haryana High Court
The Court was hearing a plea challenging the scheme on the ground that it sole purpose is to secure votes in favour of the Aam Aadmi Party government in Punjab.
The plea said that the mandatory requirement of the voter ID card of Punjab State for getting the scheme benefits clearly indicated that its object is only to secure votes from the beneficiaries.
While eligible women from the general category receive ₹1,000 per month under the scheme, those belonging to Scheduled Castes receive ₹1,500 monthly.
The scheme has been challenged by way of a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by Harbakhsh Charitable Society.
As per the petition, while Voter ID card can be one of the documents required for the purposes of identification, requiring it mandatorily for the grant of benefit under the scheme manifests its purpose, that is to act as a quid pro quo for securing votes.
According to the PIL, the Punjab government repeatedly pleads financial constraints before the Court when asked to discharge its admitted statutory liabilities towards its employees and pensioners but yet, it continues to incur substantial recurring expenditure upon discretionary subsidy or freebie schemes.
Advocates Varun Dutta and Karan Bhardwaj represent the petitioners.