Calcutta High Court 
Litigation News

Calcutta High Court closes plea for probe into death of student who died after drinking extremely hot tea

The Court noted that a chargesheet has already been filed after a police investigation in the matter.

Ekoparna Datta Ray

The Calcutta High Court on Thursday declined to entertain a plea seeking directions for an independent, impartial and transparent investigation into the death of a class 12 student after he drank scalding hot tea at his school's canteen [Manaranjan Mahata v. State of West Bengal].

The petition had been filed by Manaranjan Mahata (petitioner), the father of the deceased boy, who was a student of a school run by the Ramkrishna Mission at Narendrapur, Kolkata.

Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya who heard the matter, noted that the student had died on June 30, 2026 and that a charge sheet has already been filed after a criminal investigation by the police.

The High Court, therefore, was not inclined to issue further directions.

Justice Bhattacharyya, however, clarified that the petitioner was at liberty to seek further police investigation under Section 193 (9) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, into the circumstances surrounding his son's death.

"Chargesheet dated 9th September, 2026 is filed on concluding investigation. If petitioner (the father) is dissatisfied with the manner of investigation and chargesheet filed, on conclusion of such investigation, in that event, he has remedy under Section 193 (9) of the BNSS, 2023 by approaching jurisdictional magistrate seeking further investigation," the Court observed.

Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya

In his plea, Mahata had primarily prayed for a direction upon the police to conduct an impartial and transparent investigation into the circumstances surrounding the death of his boy and for the appointment of a retired Judge to monitor the investigation.

According to the plea, the school authorities were aware that the boy was showing signs of illness soon after drinking the hot tea. Mahata claimed that they contacted him at a belated stage, several hours after the incident when the condition of the boy had already transitioned from bad to worse.

It was also alleged that timely medical attention was not provided to the boy at the school premises, which further worsened his condition.

A subsequent post-mortem report showed that the boy succumbed to asphyxia resulting from laryngeal oedema, following thermal injury to the upper respiratory and upper gastro-oesophageal tract.

The plea also underscored that the CCTV footage recording of the events leading up to the boy's death had not been adequately preserved.

Mahata's counsel argued that the Mission was asked to take the boy to the hospital but they refused even though they had the necessary transportation facilities at their disposal.

The Ramkrishna Mission's counsel denied all these allegations, contending that the boy was declared dead only upon arrival at the hospital and that the school could not be held liable since he did not die within the premises of the educational institution.

Justice Bhattacharyya was not impressed with the Mission's stance.

"But the incident of having the breakfast was within the school premises and after examining the son of the petitioner, what steps did your institution take?" he questioned the counsel.

The judge added,

"Why did the institution wait till the father came? ... Why was he not sent directly to the hospital for immediate treatment?"

The State, meanwhile, assured the Court that the relevant CCTV footage had been preserved.

The Court ultimately declined to issue any further direction in the matter, but clarified that the boy's father was free to approach the concerned authorities for further investigation.

Ship can't be arrested to recover wages of another vessel's crew under same management: Kerala High Court

NCLT declines to revive Essar Group's OGD Services despite settlement of financial debts

Will examine whether case on private university audit needs to continue: Supreme Court after Bench change

BJP government does it in Delhi: Punjab defends voter ID mandate to avail women's scheme benefits

Restaurants and hotels cannot levy mandatory service charge: Delhi High Court clarifies

SCROLL FOR NEXT