The Delhi High Court on Thursday refused to entertain ten intellectual property suits on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction.
Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav said that the suits had only a weak link/ connection to Delhi and the same was insufficient for the Court to hear them.
The suits included patent disputes involving Novartis and Waaree Energies and a design infringement suit filed by Nyra Chocolates.
The judge applied his November 3 ruling in ABD Maestro Private Limited v. Great Galleon Ventures Ltd, in which he had similarly refused to entertain the plaints in 17 commercial suits.
The judge said that even where part of the cause of action arose in Delhi, the Court could decline to hear the suit if the dispute had a stronger connection to another forum.
“A slender connection with Delhi ought not to become a reason to deprive another court of its rightful and appropriate jurisdiction over a given lis,” the Court said.
The judgment comes less than two weeks after a larger bench of the High Court reserved its verdict on the same issue. During that hearing, lawyers had questioned certain aspects of the ABD Maestro ruling, including its treatment of purchases arranged by investigators.
In Novartis’ patent suit against Lucius Pharmaceuticals and two other defendants, the Court accepted that part of the cause of action arose in Delhi, where the allegedly infringing version of the cancer drug Dabrafenib was sold. It nevertheless held that Mumbai had a closer connection to the dispute. Novartis’ Indian affiliate, which held the marketing and import licence for the drug, was based there.
The scope of the injunction sought was what weighed in the patent suit filed by German company Gebr Schmid against Waaree Energies. Schmid relied on a sale invoice and an investigator’s purchase to bring the case before the Delhi High Court. The Court said that even assuming an offer for sale and delivery happened in Delhi, Schmid wanted an injunction that would also stop manufacture. The products were made in Surat, where the Court found the dispute was centred.
The Court took a similar approach in a suit over the alleged copying of turbojet engines. Justice Kaurav said Delhi High Court could have heard a claim confined to exports from the city. However, the plaintiffs were seeking a wider injunction covering engines manufactured in Punjab, where the alleged breach of confidentiality also took place.
In a confectionery jar dispute, Nyra Chocolates relied on a “trap order” placed with a dealer in Bihar and sent to Badarpur in Delhi. The Court found that the bill was unsigned and that Nyra had not provided enough details to assess whether the transaction was fair.
Since Nyra’s agent paid the freight charges, the Court treated the handover to the carrier as delivery to Nyra in Indore. The bill also specified that disputes would be subject to Siwan jurisdiction alone.
The remaining suits were filed by Sotkon, Mold-Tek Packaging, HLE Glascoat, Plusplus Lifesciences, Global Music Junction and Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories. The Court returned all ten plaints for presentation before the appropriate courts.
Senior Advocate J Sai Deepak appeared for Gebr Schmid, HLE Glascoat and Global Music Junction in their respective suits.
Senior Advocates Sandeep Sethi and Gaurav Miglani appeared for První Brněnská Strojírna Velká Bíteš and PBS India in the turbojet engine dispute.
Senior Advocate Rajeshwari Hariharan appeared for Plusplus Lifesciences and its co-plaintiffs.
[Read Judgment]