The Madras High Court recently refused to restrain the exploitation and distribution of the Hindi film Drishyam: The Conclusion, starring Ajay Devgn and Tabu, including its release on OTT platforms, amid a copyright dispute involving the remake rights of the Drishyam franchise [Rajkumar Theatres Vs Wide Angle].
Justice PB Balaji dismissed an interim injunction application filed by Rajkumar Theatres Private Limited, which claimed that it held rights to remake the original Malayalam film Drishyam and its sequels in Hindi.
The Court held that Rajkumar Theatres had failed to establish a prima facie case of copyright infringement.
It also noted that an application under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act in the matter had earlier been dismissed on merits. The Court held that the company could not now seek the same interim relief in a civil suit since the earlier dismissal of the Section 9 application would operate as res judicata against any fresh plea for identical interim relief.
"The test is to see whether the relief sought for in the Section 9 application has been decided on merits or not, and if so, then there is a clear, explicit res judicata for operating against the applicant/plaintiff to press for the very same relief before this court."
The dispute arose from a series of agreements concerning the Hindi remake rights of the Malayalam film Drishyam, originally released in 2013.
Under a December 2013 agreement, the original Malayalam film's producer and director granted Wide Angle Creations exclusive rights to remake, dub and adapt the film and its sequels in Hindi and other North Indian languages.
In June 2014, Wide Angle Creations entered into an agreement with Rajkumar Theatres for the joint development and commercial exploitation of the Hindi remake.
Rajkumar Theatres claimed that these agreements gave it rights over subsequent Hindi adaptations, including Drishyam 3.
However, the producers of the Hindi film argued that Drishyam: The Conclusion was an independent adaptation and not a remake or sequel covered by the earlier agreements.
The Court examined four agreements executed between 2013 and 2025 and concluded that Rajkumar Theatres had acquired commercial exploitation rights relating to the Hindi remake of the original film, rather than the entirety of the copyright held by the original creators.
"The applicant/plaintiff has not prima facie been able to satisfy me as to how they had a subsisting right to prevent the original copyright owners from assigning the adaptation rights in favour of the respondents (producers)," the Court observed.
It also rejected Rajkumar Theatres' argument that the filmmakers had deliberately dropped the numeral '3' from the movie's title to circumvent its rights.
The Court noted that although promotional materials had referred to the film as Drishyam 3, its censor certificate identified it as Drishyam: The Conclusion.
The Court further observed that Rajkumar Theatres had not specifically demonstrated how the released film infringed its claimed rights.
Accordingly, the Rajkumar Theatre's application was dismissed.
Senior Advocate K Ravi, instructed by advocate R Murugan of Rugan & Arya, appeared for Rajkumar Theatres.
Senior Advocate PS Raman, instructed by advocate Rahul Balaji, appeared for Digital 18 Media Private Limited (co-producer of Drishyam: The Conclusion).
Senior Advocate Sathish Parasaran, instructed by Advocate Akshaya Ramadurai, represented the original Malayalam film's producer and director.
Advocate K Manoj Menon appeared for Panorama Studios.
Advocates Sharath Chandran and Sowjanya Shyam appeared for Wide Angle Creations.
[Read Order]