The Madras High Court recently held that a marriage between a Hindu and a Christian cannot be solemnised or registered under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, since the legislation applies only to marriages between two Hindus [Naveen Kumar Vs Vigneshwari].
A Division Bench of Justices CV Karthikeyan and S Raveekumar held that registration under Section 8 of the Act cannot validate a marriage that does not satisfy the conditions prescribed under Section 5.
"A conjoint reading of Sections 5 and 8 of the Hindu Marriage Act makes it clear that a marriage between a Hindu and a person professing a different religion cannot be solemnized and validated by a mere registration under the said Act," the Court observed
The ruling came in an appeal filed by a man seeking to invalidate his marriage registered with a woman in February 2009.
The man alleged that the woman had misled him into visiting the registrar's office to sign as a witness to another marriage. The woman denied the allegation and maintained that the marriage had taken place with his consent.
The family court dismissed the man's suit in 2019, disbelieving his claim that he was a Christian.
However, the High Court examined baptism certificates issued in 1998 and 2006 and concluded that he was a Christian when the marriage was registered.
The Bench also found that no marriage ceremony had taken place before registration, despite the marriage certificate recording otherwise.
After examining the legal position, the Court explained that Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act permits marriages only between two Hindus, while Section 8 merely provides for registration of such marriages.
It further held that Section 7A, which recognises self-respect marriages in Tamil Nadu, would not apply if either party was not a Hindu.
The Court clarified that marriages between Christians and persons of other religions could be solemnised under the Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872, subject to compliance with its procedures.
Alternatively, the Special Marriage Act of 1954 provides a statutory mechanism for interfaith marriages.
Since neither procedure had been followed, the Bench held that the registration under the Hindu Marriage Act could not confer validity on the marriage.
Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Gullipilli Sowria Raj v. Bandaru Pavani, the Court set aside the family court's judgment and declared the marriage registration null and void.
It also directed that the judgment be circulated among marriage registrars across Tamil Nadu to ensure compliance with statutory requirements.
Advocates N Easwaran and R Veeramani appeared for the appellant