The Madras High Court recently held that a trader who does not belong to the Jain community cannot claim to have honestly adopted the name of a Jain deity as a trademark [Kailash Chand Surana Vs Shiv Mangal]
Justice PB Balaji made the observation on November 13, while granting an interim injunction in favour of Chennai-based Kalptaru Enterprise, which had alleged trademark infringement and passing off by Bengaluru-based AJ and Sons.
The Court found the defendant's adoption of the mark SNE NAKODA to be dishonest and not bona fide.
"Firstly, I see the user of the mark to be dishonest and not bonafide for the simple reason that though NAKODA is a descriptive word referring to a Jain god, the respondent does not even belong to the Jain community to claim to have adopted the mark NAKODA honestly," the Court observed.
The dispute arose from a commercial suit filed by Kailash Chand Surana, sole proprietor of Kalptaru Enterprise, against Shiv Mangal Singh, proprietor of AJ and Sons.
Surana submitted that he was into the business of manufacturing and selling metal screws since 2017 and held several trademark registrations, including NAKODA PROPLUS and PRO NAKODA.
He submitted that the mark SNE NAKODA originated from the name of an earlier partnership firm, Sree Nakoda Enterprises, established in 2007.
Singh subsequently adopted the mark SNE NAKODA FASTENING SYSTEM for identical hardware products, creating confusion among customers, it was argued.
However, Singh contended that no trader can claim exclusive rights over the name of the Jain deity. He also argued that neither party possessed a registration for SNE NAKODA and that his business operated in a different geographical market.
However, the Court found that Surana had established prima facie use of SNE NAKODA since September 2017 while Singh had to substantiate his claim of using the mark since January 2021.
The Court further observed that the similarity between their marks was likely to confuse consumers as both businesses dealt in metal screws.
"Considering the fact that the applicant as well as the respondent are in the same line of business, dealing with metal screws, clever and mischievous duplication of the name of the applicant, would be sufficient to confuse the consumers in market," the Court said.
Singh also argued that the Surana's turnover of ₹25 crore was insignificant since several companies had recorded substantially higher revenues. Rejecting this submission, the Court held that turnover has to be assessed in the context of the products being sold.
It also observed that achieving ₹25 crore in sales of relatively inexpensive metal nuts and screws demonstrates substantial commercial success.
Accordingly, the Court allowed both interim applications and restrained Singh from infringing Surana's marks and passing off his goods during the pendency of the suit.
Advocate A Jayesh Kumar Daga appeared for Surana.
Advocate V Arunagiri appeared for Singh.
[Read Order]