Former Supreme Court judge Justice Sanjay Karol has described the seven-year litigation surrounding the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) arbitral award as an aberration, defending the Indian judiciary's approach to arbitration.
Speaking at Dubai Arbitration Week 2026, Justice Karol said India had a robust arbitration framework and that courts took the adjudication and enforcement of arbitral awards seriously.
"Just not to defend the Indian judiciary, but what has been said by my co-panelist: that seven-year DMRC matter is just an aberration, if I may use that expression," he said.
"So to my colleagues here upon the panel: India is a destination, we welcome you there, and we have really a very robust system out there, both as far as adjudication is concerned and as far as the courts' approach is concerned and enforceability is concerned. So we take it very, very seriously. That is one aberration, I'm sure," he added.
The panel, organised by Chamber One Advocates and Karol, Bhadoria & Associates, featured Justice Karol, Divyam Agarwal of JSA, Ed Crosse of Simmons & Simmons and Abdul Sattar Pirzada of Khaled Almarri & Partners. It was moderated by Pranay Chitale of Chamber One Advocates.
Earlier, Agarwal had raised concerns about repeated judicial intervention in arbitral awards, citing the DMRC litigation as an example of uncertainty faced by commercial parties.
The dispute concerned an arbitral award in favour of Delhi Airport Metro Express Private Limited (DAMEPL), a Reliance Infrastructure subsidiary, arising from the termination of its concession agreement with DMRC.
The award was upheld by a single judge of the Delhi High Court but subsequently set aside by a Division Bench. The Supreme Court restored it in 2021 before setting it aside in April 2024 while allowing DMRC's curative petition.
Agarwal questioned how parties could have confidence in arbitration when courts arrived at conflicting conclusions over seven years.
"We should have finality attached to things if we want to claim ourselves to be an arbitration hub," he said.
Citing a study on challenges under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act, Agarwal said approximately 19 per cent of challenges succeeded before the Delhi High Court, compared with 46.6 per cent in Mumbai and 37.73 per cent in Madras.
He also expressed reservations about the Supreme Court's Gayatri Balasamy ruling recognising limited judicial powers to modify arbitral awards. He supported Justice KV Viswanathan's minority opinion, warning that modification powers could encourage lower courts to reopen disputes.
Justice Karol, meanwhile, emphasised that courts could interfere with arbitral awards only on limited statutory grounds.
"By and large, I would say this: that the courts are circumspect. They do not allow everything to be opened up," he said.
Crosse said excessive judicial intervention could discourage parties from choosing a jurisdiction as the seat of arbitration. He explained that English courts generally intervened only in exceptional circumstances, including fraud and serious procedural irregularities.
Pirzada highlighted the comparatively restrictive approach of the DIFC and ADGM Courts to setting aside awards. He also stressed the importance of freezing injunctions and asset disclosure orders in effective enforcement.
The discussion also addressed difficulties in enforcing UAE-seated arbitral awards in India.
Agarwal pointed out that although both countries were signatories to the New York Convention, India had not notified the UAE for the purposes of enforcing foreign arbitral awards under its Arbitration Act.
He urged the government to address the gap, particularly considering the growing commercial relations between the two countries.