Litigation News

Supreme Court flags health risks of marriages between close relatives; urges Centre to bring law, raise awareness

"This is an area of definite concern to all of us," CJI Kant observed while hearing a petition seeking measures to prevent consanguineous marriages.

Debayan Roy

The Supreme Court on Friday expressed concern over the potential health risks of marriages between close blood relatives and said that the Union government should consider suitable legislation or measures to raise awareness about the risks associated with consanguineous marriages.

A Bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana issued limited notice to the Central government on a petition highlighting the issue.

"Issue notice for the limited purpose of impressing upon the Union of India to consider the desirability of suitable legislation, or to ensure wide publicity through different channels, including a proper curriculum in schools and colleges, to instill scientific temper towards the negative impacts of consanguineous marriages," the Court said.

Justice Joymalya Bagchi, CJI Surya Kant and Justice V Mohana

The Court was hearing a petition by Bengaluru-based Charvi S, a law student with visual impairment. She suffers from retinitis pigmentosa and cone dystrophy, conditions that cause progressive visual impairment.

Born to parents who are first cousins, the petitioner has attributed her genetic disorders to the consanguineous marriage. Her plea seeks judicial and government intervention to prevent such unions, particularly among communities where the practice remains prevalent.

The plea highlights the risks of hereditary disorders and disabilities among children born from marriages between close blood relatives, while seeking greater public awareness and safeguards to protect future generations.

During the hearing of the plea, CJI Kant observed,

"This is an area of definite concern to all of us."

Justice Bagchi observed that the judiciary cannot interfere with an individual's freedom to choose a marriage partner.

"This Court has dealt with this. There was a case concerning marriage involving an HIV-positive person, where the Court said that it is a matter of personal choice. A person wishing to marry someone who is HIV-positive exercises his or her personal choice. Courts cannot regulate it by imposing a mandate," the Court said.

However, Justice Bagchi acknowledged the importance of awareness.

"But you may say that the decision should be an informed decision," he added.

The judge further clarified that reconsidering consanguineous marriages as a customary practice through social reform legislation was exclusively a legislative function.

"We would not want to tread into that," Justice Bagchi said.

Counsel representing the petitioner submitted that such marriages are prevalent in rural communities, where people are often unaware of the potential consequences for their children.

It was also submitted that the prevalence of such marriages in certain southern States is as high as 28 per cent.

CJI Kant suggested that Anganwadi workers and panchayats could be involved in spreading awareness.

The Court also acknowledged the efforts of the visually impaired law student behind the petition, who is stated to have 40 per cent visual impairment.

"We have full sympathy with this girl, and thank you for taking up this assignment," CJI Kant remarked.

Marriage between Hindu and Christian cannot be registered under Hindu Marriage Act: Madras High Court

Access to a chatbot is not access to justice: Senior Advocate Rajshekhar Rao

Dismissal disguised as transfer? Bombay High Court directs Bosch to pay ₹25 lakh each to retrenched workers

The case for fast-tracking reforms in India to recognise emergency arbitration in statute

Don't stop training young lawyers: Justice Manmeet Arora on law firms using AI to cut costs

SCROLL FOR NEXT