The Supreme Court on Wednesday set aside the State of Odisha’s acquisition of land in three villages in Sundargarh district for a Dalmia Cement mining project. [Bibol Toppo v. Odisha]
A Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma held that the State proceeded without obtaining the mandatory consent of the gram sabhas and affected families. It overturned the Orissa High Court’s September 2024 judgment upholding the acquisition.
It further said that the High Court’s treatment of gram sabha consent had “the effect of reducing a mandatory statutory requirement into a paper formality.”
“Far from a meaningful consent, there is not even paper consent of Gram Sabha in this case,” the Court said, noting that both gram sabhas had rejected the proposal in January 2020.
Dalmia Cement already held a mining lease extending to 2040. In 2015, it asked the Odisha government to acquire surface rights over agricultural land in Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna so it could expand mining operations. The State went ahead with the acquisition despite the resolutions rejecting it. Residents of the three villages challenged the proceedings.
The High Court had held that the requirement of consent from 80 per cent of affected families did not apply because title to the land would vest in the State. It also held that even if such consent was required, it could be gathered at different stages of the acquisition.
The Supreme Court held that the purpose of the acquisition determined which safeguards applied. The land was sought exclusively for mining by a private company. Section 2(2)(b) of the 2013 land acquisition law, therefore, required the consent of at least 80 per cent of affected families during the social impact assessment, before the State examined the proposal. Consent obtained at a later stage could not cure the defect.
The Bench held that Section 41(3) imposed a separate requirement of prior gram sabha consent because the land fell within a Scheduled Area under the Fifth Schedule to the Constitution. The requirement applied even to urgent acquisitions.
The Court also found no evidence that the mandatory public hearing on the draft social impact assessment had taken place. Replies obtained under the Right to Information Act indicated that the hearing could not be held due to COVID-19 restrictions and that the final assessment did not record the views of affected residents.
The Bench further held that including a Dalmia Cement land acquisition adviser on the expert group that reviewed the assessment compromised its statutory independence.
“It had the effect of rendering the deliberation of the Expert Group as a fixed match,” it said.
The Court said that the mining lease governed the relationship between Odisha and Dalmia Cement. Once the State chose to acquire land under the 2013 law, it had to comply with that law’s safeguards. The Bench quashed the acquisition and the related notifications and orders.
Senior Advocate Sanjay Parikh appeared for the appellants with advocates Sridevi Panikkar, Ashok Kumar Minj, Kritika and Satwik Parikh.
Additional Solicitor General KM Nataraj and Odisha Advocate General Pitambar Acharya appeared for the State with advocates Deveshi Mishra, Vinayak Sharma, Ruturaj Satpathy and Yogya Rajpurohit.
Senior Advocate Rakesh Dwivedi appeared for Dalmia Cement with advocates Mahesh Agarwal, MS Ananth, Kamakshi Sehgal, Paranjai Singh, Eklavya Dwivedi and Mohd Yasir.
[Read Judgment]