Srinagar Bench, Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court 
News

Mere claim that man contacted terrorist through VPN not enough to order preventive detention: J&K High Court

The Court observed that although the allegation was serious, the power of preventive detention cannot be employed as a substitute for ordinary criminal proceedings.

Mohsin Dar

The Jammu and Kashmir High Court recently quashed preventive detention orders issued against a man in 2025 on allegations that he used an encrypted application or (Virtual Private Network) VPN to content persons with links to terrorist organisations [Ajaz Ahmed Seh V/s Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir].

Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal acknowledged that the allegations were serious, but went on to note that the authorities had not produced any material to support such claims.

"The mere assertion that the detenue used an encrypted application or a VPN, or remained in contact with persons alleged to be associated with terrorist organisations, cannot, without further particulars and relevant supporting material, furnish an adequate basis for curtailing personal liberty through preventive detention," the Court observed.

The Court warned that a preventive detention order cannot be invoked merely by making serious allegations to bypass the procedural safeguards part of ordinary criminal law and keep a person in preventive detention when evidence as required by the law is yet to be secured.

"Preventive detention legislation cannot be permitted to become an instrument for bypassing the safeguards of the ordinary criminal process or for detaining a person on the strength of allegations that remain insufficiently particularised

Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal

The Court was hearing a plea to quash a preventive detention order passed against a driver (petitioner) in July 2025.

The authorities claimed that the petitioner had remained in contact with a person described as a terrorist handler affiliated with Jaish-e-Mohammad (JeM). This was alleged to have been done through a telephone number and the encrypted application Zangi, allegedly accessed through a secured VPN, for communicating with handlers based in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir/Pakistan.

The authorities further alleged that the petitioner was functioning as an Over Ground Worker (OGW) by providing food, shelter, clothing, transportation and information to active terrorists, including an alleged active terrorist from Kachipora, Rajpora, Pulwama.

His counsel argued that these allegations were largely based on presumptions and conjectures.

The High Court observed that preventive detention is a precautionary measure and not a substitute for the ordinary criminal process.

Examining the allegations against the petitioner, the Court noted that although the alleged association with terrorist handlers and the provision of logistical assistance were serious allegations, the grounds of detention lacked the necessary particulars.

It pointed out that there was no clear indication of the specific dates on which the alleged communications took place, the nature or substance of the information exchanged, or the particular acts through which logistical assistance was allegedly rendered by the petitioner.

The Court further held that if the investigating agency possessed material indicating that the petitioner had used electronic communications to coordinate terrorist activities,such material could have been examined and acted upon under the applicable criminal law, including the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967.

"The allegations, if supported by cogent material, are undoubtedly serious and warrant appropriate action in accordance with law," it said.

However, it found that there was nothing to indicate that preventive detention was justified in this case.

“The power of preventive detention, being an extraordinary invasion of personal liberty, must be exercised sparingly, cautiously and only in strict conformity with the constitutional and statutory safeguards governing its exercise. The object of such detention is to prevent a person from engaging in activities prejudicial to the security of the State or other interests specified under the relevant law, and not to punish him for alleged acts already committed … The mere existence of allegations of a serious nature cannot, by itself, justify recourse to preventive detention. The authority must apply its mind to whether the circumstances genuinely warrant preventive detention and whether the statutory purpose can appropriately be achieved through the ordinary criminal law," the Court underscored.

Advocate Mohammad Ayoub Bhat assisted by advocate Mahajabeen Bhat appeared for the petitioner.

Government Advocate Jahangir Ahmad Dar appeared for the Jammu and Kashmir authorities.

[Read Order]

ajaz-ahmad-seh-vs-ut-of-J&K.pdf
Preview

RISE Legal India: 300 lawyers to gather in Mumbai as RSGI reveals its 2026 Resight India Law Firm Ratings

Seven-year DMRC arbitration battle an aberration: Former Justice Sanjay Karol defends Indian judiciary

Commercial law monologues: Should a witness be cross-examined when oral evidence is contradicted by documentary evidence?

Bombay High Court dismisses EuroChem appeal in ₹19,500-crore Tecnimont dispute

Senior Advocate TR Rajagopalan passes away

SCROLL FOR NEXT