The Delhi High Court on Thursday made it clear that it had not granted any interim relief to restaurants against an earlier order banning the mandatory levy of service charges in restaurants and hotels.
A Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice (ACJ) Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma said that no interim relief had been granted against the single-judge's March 28, 2025 order.
The Court issued the clarification after Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Chetan Sharma appeared for the government and stated that in some restaurants, service charge was still mandatory.
Sharma said that this violated the single judge's order, which upheld guidelines issued by the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) in 2022 stipulating that hotels and restaurants should not add service charges automatically or by default to food bills.
"Ball is in your court. It is for you to take action. We can't take action. Where is the interim relief? Where is the interim relief in their favour? We have not granted any interim prayer," ACJ Sambre replied.
The Court was hearing appeals filed by the National Restaurant Association of India (NRAI) and the Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI) against the single judge's order.
Today, it admitted those appeals for hearing.
In July 2022, the CCPA issued guidelines prohibiting restaurants from forcibly collecting service charges. This followed numerous consumer complaints about the practice of adding 5–20 per cent of service charges to food bills without the customer's consent.
The CCPA guidelines were challenged before the High Court by the NRAI and the FHRAI, who argued that the practice was an 80-year-old industry norm linked to labour agreements.
However, the a single judge of the Court found no evidence that service charges directly benefited employees.
The single judge ruled that service charges must be voluntary and that compelling customers to pay them amounts to an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
The Court also confirmed that the CCPA has statutory authority under the Consumer Protection Act to regulate unfair practices and that the guidelines have the binding force of law.
The single judge further banned the misleading use of the term "service charge," noting that it may mislead consumers into thinking that they are government taxes. Restaurants were directed to use clearer terms such as “voluntary contribution” or “staff welfare fund" for such charges.
Restaurants were also ordered to ensure that there is no automatic addition of such charges to bills. Customers must be informed clearly that tipping is voluntary, the Court said.
The NRAI, in its appeal, has argued that service charges, when clearly disclosed on the menu and at the restaurant, do not amount to an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. It has submitted that a service charge is a long-standing industry practice, recognised by the Supreme Court, High Courts, Wage Boards, and labour settlements, and that it forms part of employee compensation.
The NRAI added that this case raises questions on whether the issue falls under labour law, rather than consumer law, and whether the CCPA has jurisdiction to regulate pricing structures that are disclosed and accepted by customers at the time of placing orders.