Ship (for representation purpose only) 
News

Ship can't be arrested to recover wages of another vessel's crew under same management: Kerala High Court

The Court observed that a vessel could be arrested in such circumstances only if, prima facie, there was a commonality of interest between the owners of the ships, along with a clear intention to defraud a creditor.

Praisy Thomas

The Kerala High Court on Tuesday held that a ship cannot be arrested to recover crew wages relating to another vessel merely because they are managed by the same shipping company [Light House Marine Service India Pvt Ltd v Charter and Parties interested in the Vessel MT Ocean Faye & ors].

A Division Bench of Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar VM observed that a vessel could be arrested in such circumstances only if, prima facie, there was a commonality of interest between the shipowners, along with a clear intention to defraud a creditor.

Merely because the vessels were managed by the same entity did not mean that the entity also owned them, the Court pointed out.

The Court made the observation while dismissing an appeal filed by a manning agent (crew-supply agent) named Light House Marine Service India Pvt Lt.

Light House Marine Service (appellant) had sought to arrest the vessel MT Ocean Faye to recover wages it had paid to crew members of three other vessels, all of which are managed by Star Voyages Shipping Services LLC.

The Court held that such a contractual dispute between a crew-supplying agency and a ship manager over the dues paid to the crew of certain vessels cannot justify the arrest of another vessel, merely because all the vessels involved had a common manager.

"The appellant is neither a bareboat charterer nor a demise charterer and is only a manning agent or crew supplier who claims to have entered into an agreement to supply crew to the vessels managed by the second defendant. A manning agent who has a contractual arrangement with Ship’s Manager does not stand on similar footing as a demise charter or bareboat charter qua the owner of the vessel. He is far distanced from the shipowner and his vessel and cannot, in law, aspire to arrest the vessel for his disputes and claims with the Ship’s Manager... The crucial test of ownership has not been established in the instant case," the Court held.

Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar VM (Kerala HC)

The appellant had claimed that it paid the wages of crew members aboard three vessels, namely MT Eastern Pearl, MT Fast Kathy and MT Sea Fidelity, after Star Voyages failed to make these payments despite contractual obligations to do so.

Later, Star Voyages also failed to reimburse the amount despite repeated demands by the appellant.

The appellant subsequently sought to arrest MT Ocean Faye, which was also managed by Star Voyages, to secure its claim.

In May 2024, a single-judge bench of the High Court ordered the vessel's arrest. The vessel was subsequently released after security was furnished.

Meanwhile, the vessel's interested parties challenged the arrest. A single-judge bench of the Court ruled in their favour, prompting Light House to file an appeal.

The appellant argued that Sections 4(1)(o) and 4(1)(p) read with Sections 5(2) of the Admiralty (Jurisdiction and Settlement of Maritime Claims) Act, 2017, permitted the arrest of another vessel to secure its maritime claim.

It stated that MT Ocean Faye could, therefore, be arrested as it was managed by the same company that owed the appellant money with respect to the wages of crew aboard other vessels.

The respondents (parties interested in MT Ocean Faye) opposed the appeal, arguing that the appellants had no contractual relationship with MT Ocean Faye and that the unpaid wages concerned entirely different vessels.

Examining the provisions, the Court held that Section 5(2) which permits the arrest of another vessel in certain circumstances cannot be invoked independently of the requirements prescribed under Section 5(1).

It noted that the three vessels involved in the wage dispute had no established common ownership with MT Ocean Faye and even the owners of those vessels had not been made parties to the suit.

The Court further noted that the appellant's claim was based on its agreement with the ship management company to recover the crew wages it had paid and not on any legal right over MT Ocean Faye itself.

Since the appellant had failed to establish any legal basis for arresting MT Ocean Faye, the Court found no reason to interfere with the single judge's decision setting aside the vessel's arrest.

Accordingly the Court dismissed the appeal.

Senior counsel P Viswanathan, along with advocates Ajith Viswanathan, Shibu Joseph, Vrinda babu, said Mansoor Bafakhy Thangal and M Sriram appeared for the appellant.

Senior counsel Santhosh Mathew along with Jikku Seban George appeared for the vessel MT Ocean Faye and One moon marine Services .

[Read Judgment]

Light House Marine Service India Pvt Ltd v Charter and Parties interested in the Vessel MT Ocean Faye & ors.pdf
Preview

NCLT declines to revive Essar Group's OGD Services despite settlement of financial debts

Will examine whether case on private university audit needs to continue: Supreme Court after Bench change

BJP government does it in Delhi: Punjab defends voter ID mandate to avail women's scheme benefits

Restaurants and hotels cannot levy mandatory service charge: Delhi High Court clarifies

Calcutta High Court refuses to grant interim protection to Abhishek Banerjee's aide Sumit Roy in repeated criminal cases

SCROLL FOR NEXT