While technological integration in Indian courts is no longer a matter of speculation, its deployment must be guided by constitutional values and sensitivity toward the marginalised, Madhya Pradesh High Court Chief Justice Alpesh Y Kogje said on Saturday.
He also outlined several practical avenues where AI and digital tools can overhaul justice delivery.
He was speaking at the inaugural edition of JusTech, Dharmashastra National Law University (DNLU) Jabalpur’s national conclave.
Justice Kogje opened his address with an interactive presentation walking the audience through the physical stages of filing a case and identifying two immediate areas at the initial stage where AI can be deployed effectively - case registration on the court system and scrutiny of files.
Pointing to the staggering pendency crippling Indian courts, he noted that judicial delay is far from theoretical.
"Delay is not an abstraction. It means an undertrial prisoner spending years in custody. It means property disputes outliving the parties who initiated them. It means a small entrepreneur abandoning a legitimate claim because the cost of enforcing it exceeds the value of the claim itself," he said.
However, he cautioned against viewing technology as a silver bullet.
He then proceeded to highlight the following practical avenues in the legal field where AI and digital tools can be put to use:
AI-enabled tools can guide citizens in identifying the appropriate legal forum, locating legal service institutions, and assembling required documents without relying entirely on intermediaries—provided such tools clearly distinguish general legal information from formal professional advice.
Calling it an area with "considerable scope for innovation," he proposed a coordinated digital mechanism linking District Legal Services Authorities (DLSA), prisons, police stations, and courts.
Such a system would identify eligible persons, connect them with empaneled lawyers, and monitor effective representation so that vulnerable accused persons "do not fall through the institutional gaps" at crucial stages of criminal proceedings.
AI can cluster similar matters involving common legal issues, helping courts decide them together consistently and avoid contradictory verdicts.
Looking ahead, he envisioned criminal trials utilizing 3D digital reconstructions of crime scenes built from forensic data, CCTV footage, photographs, and location records. While this would allow judges to correlate the accused, victim, and surrounding circumstances visually, he underscored that "questions of source authenticity, chain of custody, admissibility, disclosure, and the opportunity to challenge the material will remain fundamental."
However, he also highlighted barriers such as illiteracy, economic disparity, geographical distance, physical disabilities and linguistic hurdles when it comes to access to justice. In that backdrop, he asked whether AI would be one more such additional hurdle for a layperson.
"Are we adding one more hurdle for a common man if accessibility to justice is deployed with Artificial Intelligence?"
Building on the institutional framework of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, and the strides made by the Supreme Court’s e-Committee, he emphasised that true democratisation means enabling an ordinary citizen, regardless of background or disability, to know their rights, approach the right forum, participate in proceedings, and secure an affordable, timely remedy.
"Technology democratizes justice only when it is accompanied by outreach, assistance, inclusion, and sensitivity towards the last person in the queue. We must not create a situation where the digital divide becomes the new 'access to justice' divide," he warned.
To ensure technology serves as an equalizer rather than an exclusionary wall, Chief Justice Kogje laid down five non-negotiable considerations for adopting AI in the judiciary:
Digital, but not digital-only: Physical access and human assistance must remain available and accessible.
Understandable and usable: Services must be accessible in local languages and designed for persons with disabilities.
Transparent: Public access to judicial information must be carefully balanced with the protection of personal and confidential data.
Technology-assisted, but not controlled: Judicial discretion and human accountability must remain paramount.
Impact study: Processes must be evaluated at regular intervals to evolve alongside shifting societal needs and technological advances.
"The same technology which empowers a farmer may exclude a laborer. The same database used for the dispensation of justice may expose the private information of a vulnerable litigant. The same AI which translates a judgment may fabricate a precedent. Therefore, our success will depend not merely on the technology we adopt, but on the values with which we adopt it," he underscored.
[Read Live Coverage]