Apology should come from heart: Supreme Court to Sanjay Raut in contempt of court case

The Court directed both Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle to be present physically before the Court on December 8.
Sanjay Raut
Sanjay Raut
Published on: 
4 min read

The Supreme Court on Tuesday pulled up Shiv Sena (UBT) Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut in a criminal contempt of court case over his remarks against Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and the judiciary [SCBA vs. Nikhil Wagle & Anr.].

A Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi reminded Raut that as a seasoned parliamentarian he ought to exercise restraint in his speech.

The Court made the observation while hearing the contempt petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) against Raut and senior journalist Nikhil Wagle.

In compliance with the Court's earlier order, Raut was physically present in the courtroom during the hearing, while Wagle joined virtually.

Addressing Raut directly, Justice Kumar underscored that any expression of regret must be sincere.

"Mr. Raut, you are a seasoned politician. We have been hearing your political debates since our advocate days. You are an experienced parliamentarian. You should know the restraint in your words. Your apology should come from the heart," Justice Kumar remarked.

Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi
Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi

In a lighter moment during the exchange, the Bench also asked Raut in Hindi, "Aap pehle Supreme Court aayein hai?"(Have you come to the Supreme Court before?). His counsel replied that Raut had visited the Court before, though never in a contempt proceeding.

After noting that Raut’s reply affidavit was not yet on record, the Court directed both Raut and Wagle to file additional affidavits addressing all the social media posts flagged by the petitioner, and ordered both to remain physically present before the Court on the next date of hearing on December 8.

The Court was hearing a contempt petition initiated by the SCBA following consent granted by Attorney General for India R Venkataramani under Section 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.

The controversy erupted after CJI Kant declined a request by an opposition delegation led by Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi for an in-person meeting regarding the functioning of Election Commission of India.

Following the decision, Wagle posted the abusive remark on X, while Raut alleged in press interactions that 80 Supreme Court and High Court judges were seen playing badminton with political leaders in London. This was despite an existing Delhi High Court injunction against circulating such false reports.

Raut also shared a tweet referencing the burning of Albania's Supreme Court.

On October 16, a Bench led by CJI Kant had issued show-cause notices to both Wagle and Raut, calling the attacks on the judiciary "very unfortunate." On November 11, the Court directed Raut to appear physically on November 17 while permitting Wagle to join virtually.

Indira Jaising
Indira Jaising

During the hearing on Tuesday, Senior Advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for Wagle, submitted that her client had already filed an affidavit tendering a genuine and unconditional apology, deleted the offending post, and sent personal apologies to the CJI and the Attorney General.

"He is a seasoned journalist... He does not belong to any political party. He has no axe to grind against the Court," Jaising submitted, urging the Bench to accept his apology and discharge him from the proceedings.

However, Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai, appearing for the SCBA, argued that Wagle needed to file a better affidavit considering the gravity of his remarks.

You are an experienced parliamentarian. You should know the restraint in your words. Your apology should come from the heart.
Supreme Court

The Bench agreed, directing Wagle to specifically deal with his October 11 post on X, in which he had used abusive language ("f**k you CJI!") while reacting to a news report on the CJI declining an in-person meeting with the Rahul Gandhi-led opposition delegation.

"It leaves a very bad taste in our mouth to even repeat it. Unparliamentary is also too less to describe this," Justice Kumar said.

Jaising responded that while the language was neither dignified nor appropriate, there was a distinction between abusing a judge and committing contempt of court, noting that the phrase had unfortunately entered common parlance.

When the Bench indicated that both respondents would have to appear physically on December 8 to conclude the matter, Jaising quipped that she might not be able to attend in person due to Delhi's air pollution.

"Your Lordships were also not able to stop the pollution." Jaising remarked.

"Again you are blaming us," Justice Kumar smiled in response.

Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai
Senior Advocate Pradeep RaiLinkedin

The matter will be heard next on December 8 at 2 PM, with both Raut and Wagle ordered to appear in person.

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com