Kerala High Court quashes disproportionate assets case against minister KM Shaji

The Court held that the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau could not register the FIR without obtaining the sanction required under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
KM Shaji
KM Shaji
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

The Kerala High Court on Thursday quashed a First Information Report (FIR) registered by the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (VACB) against Kerala's Minister for Local Self Government, KM Shaji, in a corruption case [KM Shaji v The State of Kerala & ors].

Justice C Jayachandran held that the case was registered without getting the necessary sanction under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act).

The Court said that the VACB should have submitted its preliminary enquiry report to the special court instead of proceeding to register an FIR without the necessary sanction.

It explained that since the enquiry had been ordered by the special court, any subsequent investigation had to comply with the sanction requirement under Section 19 of the PC Act.

"For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the opinion that Ext.P4 F.I.R cannot be sustained, as the same is registered without sanction under Section 19 of the P.C Act. The Investigating Officer should have followed the course suggested in Ext.P2, that is to say, to file a report before the learned Special Judge, so as to enable the Special Judge to take a call as to whether an investigation under Section 156(3) has to be ordered," the Court said.

However, it clarified that the authorities could proceed with the preliminary enquiry in accordance with the special court's earlier directions.

The order was passed on a petition filed by Shaji challenging the FIR registered by the VACB against him in 2021.

Justice C Jayachandran
Justice C Jayachandran

The case arose from a complaint filed by advocate MR Harish before the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge at Kozhikode in November 2020.

The Special Judge directed the investigating officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry and submit a report.

However, the VACB subsequently registered an FIR on April 11, 2021, alleging offences under Sections 13(1)(e) and 13(1)(b) read with Section 13(2) of the PC Act, which deals with criminal misconduct involving disproportionate assets and illicit enrichment by a public servant.

Shaji approached the High Court challenging the FIR stating that it was illegal.

The prosecution opposed the plea arguing that the special court had only directed a preliminary enquiry and that the investigating officer could register in FIR if a cognisable offence emerged during that enquiry.

After examining the contentions, the High Court distinguished between an investigation initiated independently by the police and the one arising from a magistrate's direction under Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

It held that although a preliminary enquiry could be ordered without sanction, the investigating officer could not register an FIR pursuant to that enquiry without complying with Section 19 of the PC Act.

"However, registration of an F.I.R by the Investigating Officer during the scope of a preliminary enquiry requires sanction under Section 19, as the source of the Investigating Officer's power is traceable only to Section 156(3); and not to Section 156(1)," the Court said.

It further held that the investigating officer should have submitted a report to the special court, enabling it to decide whether a formal investigation was necessary.

The Court consequently quashed the FIR and all subsequent proceedings arising from it.

However, it rejected Shaji's challenge to the special court's preliminary enquiry order, noting that his petition did not specifically seek to quash it.

Advocates Babu S Nair and Smitha Babu appeared for Shaji.

Public prosecutor Sameer S appeared for the State.

Advocates CV Manuvilsan, Naeem Ibrahim, OA Anju and Vrinda Lakshmanan appeared for the complainant.

[Read Judgment]

Attachment
PDF
KM Shaji v The State of Kerala & ors
Preview
Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com