Kerala High Court sends plea challenging closure of vigilance probe against CM VD Satheesan to Chief Justice

Punarjani was a flood rehabilitation initiative launched in 2018 by CM Satheesan, then the MLA representing Paravur, to assist families affected by floods in the State.
Kerala HC, MLA VD Satheesan
Kerala HC, MLA VD Satheesan
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

The Kerala High Court today directed its registry to place before the Chief Justice a plea challenging the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau's (VACB's) decision to close its preliminary enquiry into allegations of irregularities in the Punarjani rehabilitation project launched by cuirrent Chief Minister VD Satheeshan in 2018 [Adv KM Shajahan v State of Kerala & ors]

Justice C Jayachandran observed that the petition appeared to have the character of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) petition and thus, the question of the petitioner's locus standi should also be examined by a Bench with the PIL roster.

The Court said that it would not be appropriate for one Bench to decide whether the petitioner had the legal standing to approach the Court only for the matter to be placed before another Bench.

"It cannot be conceived in law that the question of locus can be considered by one court, and if the petitioner is found to have locus, the matter will have to be placed before the court having jurisdiction as per law," the Court explained.

Justice C Jayachandran
Justice C Jayachandran

The petition, filed by advocate KM Shajahan, seeks to set aside the Vigilance Director's May 26 decision closing the inquiry, and to enforce recommendations made in earlier vigilance reports.

Punarjani was a flood rehabilitation initiative launched in 2018 by CM Satheesan, then the MLA representing Paravur, to assist families affected by floods in the State.

The petition alleges that Satheesan solicited foreign contributions during a private visit to United Kingdom in October 2018 in violation of the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA).

According to the plea, a preliminary inquiry report on April 5, 2025 flagged the alleged collection of £22,500 at an event in Birmingham and questioned financial transactions worth approximately ₹1.22 crore involving Kochi-based Manappatt Foundation and its chairman Ameer Ahamed.

The petition states the then Vigilance Director recommended a CBI inquiry to the State government on April 30, 2025.

However, the relevant authorities subsequently sought further clarifications from the investigating officer, following which a revised preliminary report was submitted on May 7, 2026.

The revised report did not overturn the earlier findings but the Vigilance Director nevertheless closed the inquiry on May 26, 2026.

During the hearing today, Shajahan's counsel argued that as a citizen and a whistleblower, he was entitled to challenge the vigilance authority's decision to close the enquiry, even though he was not among the original complainants.

Advocate General Jaju Babu opposed the submission, pointing out that one of the original complainants, Jaison Panikulangara, had previously approached the High Court seeking a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) inquiry into the Punarjani project.

A Division Bench had on December 9, 2020, rejected his PIL and directed the complainant to pursue remedies available under the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), the Court was told.

AG Babu further argued that Shajahan, being a third-party who had not initiated the original complaint, lacks the locus standi to pursue the present challenge before the Court.

The Court after hearing the submissions, noted that the earlier proceedings had been pursued under PIL jurisdiction and found a strong prima facie ground that the present plea, if considered on merits, should also be heard by a Bench dealing with PIL matters.

"In such circumstances, there exists a strong prima facie indication that the petition, if at all liable to be considered on merits, partakes the character of a public interest litigation, liable to be considered by the Bench having jurisdiction as per the roster, and not by this Court," the Court said.

Thus, it requested the registry to place the matter before the Chief Justice for appropriate orders.

The petitioner was represented by advocates V Sethunath and Shamnas S.

[Read live coverage]

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com