

The Calcutta High Court on Friday upheld murder charges against a building promoter in connection with the collapse of a five-storey building being developed by him and others in 2024, which claimed fifteen lives [Md. Wasim @ Wassi v. State of West Bengal and Anr]
Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das dismissed the revision petition filed by the accused Wasim for quashing the charges framed against him by the trial court. The Court observed that altering the charges would negatively impact the trial proceedings.
"This Court is of the considered view that if at this threshold stage, charge is altered and a charge for substantially lesser offence is framed there would hardly remain any scope for the prosecution to proceed effectively with the trial in respect of the gravity of the allegation and the role attributed to the petitioner, even if later found some ingredients against the petitioner for commission of grave offence", the Court observed.
The Court added that the trial court would be at liberty to examine the necessary evidence and decide the ultimate fate of the prosecution case during the trial.
"The Court shall, therefore, have the liberty to determine the culpability of the petitioner and the ultimate of the case upon proper appreciation of the evidences to be adduced in course of trial, " it said.
The five-storey building had collapsed at Azhar Molla Bagan in Kolkata on March 18, 2024. A subsequent inspection by Kolkata Municipal Corporation revealed that the construction lacked the necessary approvals.
A trial court in December 2024 charged the accused under Sections 302 (murder), 307 (attempt to murder), 427 (Mischief causing damage to the amount of fifty rupees) and 120B (criminal conspiracy) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
Challenging the framing of charges, Wasim's counsel said that though he has been charged for murder and other serious offences by the trial court, the complaint letter based on which the police conducted the investigation made no mention of any act that would form the basis of these crimes.
He further argued that the element of intention or knowledge was missing in the case and thus the accused could not be tried for the offence of murder.
"The petitioner did not have the requisite degree or knowledge that on a specific date and time the building so constructed after engaging a considerable amount of fund will collapse and 15 persons including the Co-promoter, will be there to succumb to the accident," the counsel said.
However, that prosecution stated that the investigation revealed that Wasim had directed labourers to mix the ingredients of construction materials in disproportionate quantities and use inferior quality materials in raising the columns of the building. It was also submitted that the building was raised without prior approval from authorities.
Considering the allegations, the Court dismissed Wasim's plea.
"The petitioner despite possessing no requisite technical qualifications actively involved himself in the construction of the building, which ultimately collapsed, resulting in death 15 persons and injuries to several others. The prosecution has also brought to the fore, the petitioner’s alleged criminal antecedents, including antecedent relating to commission of offence of murder," it said.
Wasim was represented by advocates Sandip Kumar Bhattacharya, Dipta Dipak Banerjee, Srijita Dhar and Srilekha Dhar.
The State was represented by Public Prosecutor Kallol Mondal with advocates Pritam Roy and Samira Grewal.
[Read Order]