Former High Court Judge CS Karnan withdraws bail petition before Madras High Court

Karnan's counsel made a mention of the matter for withdrawal this morning before the Bench of Justice V Bharathidasan.
Former High Court Judge CS Karnan withdraws bail petition before Madras High Court
Justice CS Karnan

Former High Court Judge, CS Karnan today withdrew his application seeking bail in the cases registered against him for allegedly making derogatory comments against women and the judiciary in videos uploaded online.

To this end, Karnan's counsel made a mention of the matter for withdrawal this morning before the Bench of Justice V Bharathidasan.

The bail petition had been moved in the High Court after the dismissal of his bail pleas by the Metropolitan Magistrate and the Sessions Court at Chennai.

Justice CS Karnan
"Suffering from depression after retirement, incarceration": Former High Court judge Justice CS Karnan moves Madras High Court for bail

Three FIRs were registered last year against him over derogatory remarks allegedly made by him against women and the judiciary in videos uploaded online.

Writ proceedings seeking action against Karnan and the content allegedly disseminated on his behalf were also initiated by the Bar Council of Tamil Nadu and Puducherry.

Following this, the High Court passed orders directing the blocking of remarks made by Karnan from social media on November 10. With the High Court monitoring the case, the police eventually arrested Karnan.

In the bail petition before the High Court, Karnan had pointed out that he has not released any video containing obscene or vulgar language after he made an undertaking to refrain from any such conduct to the police, who had summoned him under Section 41A, of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) prior to his eventual arrest.

Karnan submitted that he has been suffering from severe depression and disturbance following his retirement and the incarceration he underwent earlier. The same had aggravated and caused him to act in an improper manner, he submitted.

He was under severe trauma and not of a proper mindset, the plea stated. He added that due to severe depression, he had acted without comprehension or realising the full consequences of his actions.

He further informed that following his arrest, he was treated at the Stanley Hospital for age-related health issues, including COVID-19. After treatment at Stanley Hospital for COVID, he was discharged and is presently confined in Central Prison 1 - Puzhal, he stated.

In this backdrop, he had urged the High Court for the grant of bail, while undertaking to co-operate with the police investigation and to abide by any condition that the Court may impose.

Karnan had served as a judge of the Madras and Calcutta High Courts, before he was held guilty of contempt of court by the Supreme Court for making unfounded allegations against the judges of the top court. He was sentenced to six months imprisonment in that case and was released from prison in December 2017.

Related Stories

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com