Karnataka High Court quashes case against man who posted that Siddaramaiah will distribute nation's wealth to Muslims

The Court held that the social media post, even if taken at face value, did not satisfy the essential ingredients of Section 153A of IPC which criminalises promoting enmity between different groups on ground of religion.
Karnataka High Court, Siddaramaiah
Karnataka High Court, SiddaramaiahSiddaramaiah (FB)
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

The Karnataka High Court recently quashed criminal proceedings against a man accused of promoting communal enmity by reposting a TV9 news clip carrying a headline that then Chief Minister Siddaramaiah would distribute the nation's wealth to Muslims.

Justice Rajesh Rai K on November 6, held that the social media post, even if taken at face value, did not satisfy the essential ingredients of Section 153A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) (promoting enmity between different groups on ground of religion).

Justice K Rajesh Rai
Justice K Rajesh Rai

The Court observed that the petitioner had merely reposted a news item disseminated by TV9, along with a photograph of the then Chief Minister, while expressing his dissent through an accompanying write-up.

"In the absence of any specific reference to two distinct groups or communities, such an act, by itself, would not attract the ingredients of Section 153A of IPC," the Court said.

The case arose from a complaint lodged on April 29, 2024, by a Congress party worker. The complainant alleged that certain persons had been posting tweets from April 22, 2024, through an account named 'BhikuMhatre (Modi's Family) @MumbaichaDon'.

One such post carried a photograph of Siddaramaiah addressing the media, accompanied by a caption alleging that the Congress manifesto specifically mentioned Muslims in the context of wealth distribution.

The complainant alleged that the post was intended to promote hatred between Hindu and Muslim communities, disturb public peace and bring disrepute to the Congress party.

Based on the complaint, Bengaluru Cyber Crime Police registered an FIR against Nayak under Section 153A IPC and Section 66(C) of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (which criminalises fraudulent or dishonest use of another person's electronic signature, password or other unique identification feature).

Senior Advocate Aruna Shyam
Senior Advocate Aruna Shyam

Senior Advocate Aruna Shyam, appearing for Nayak, argued that the petitioner had merely reposted a news clip published by TV9 and had neither humiliated any particular community nor made any statement intended to incite hatred or violence.

He also contended that the police had not verified the genuineness of the news item before registering the FIR and that the complaint was motivated by political vengeance.

Advocate BN Jagadeesh
Advocate BN Jagadeesh

The State government through special public prosecutor BN Jagadeesha argued that the petitioner had posted the news clip with the intention of creating communal hatred by suggesting that the Congress party intended to take away wealth belonging to Hindus and distribute it exclusively to Muslims.

The State also submitted that the investigation was at a nascent stage and the allegations required further investigation.

The High Court noted that the TV9 news item carried the headline, "I will share the wealth of the nation to Muslims: CM Siddaramaiah".

It also took note of the fact that no investigation had been conducted to ascertain the genuineness of the news item.

The Court reiterated that an offence under Section 153A IPC requires the promotion of enmity, hatred or ill-will between at least two distinct groups or communities.

"Merely inciting the feeling of one community or group without any reference to any other community or group cannot attract Section 153A," it said.

The Court further observed that Section 153A would apply only when an act is prejudicial to communal harmony disturbs or is likely to disturb public tranquillity.

It also underscored that the right to express dissent in a legitimate and lawful manner is an integral part of the fundamental rights, subject to reasonable restrictions.

The Court also recorded that the complainant had not appeared despite service of notice.

It cautioned that continuation of criminal proceedings based on frivolous or vexatious complaints could seriously tarnish the reputation of an accused person.

Holding that the allegations did not satisfy the essential ingredients of Section 153A IPC, the Court concluded that even if the complaint and FIR were accepted in their entirety, no offence was made out against Nayak.

"Therefore, the continuation of FIR and further proceedings against the petitioner would amount to abuse of process of court," the Court held.

Accordingly, it allowed the petition and quashed the FIR and all further proceedings against the petitioner.

Besides Aruna Shyam, advocate Suyog Herele also appeared for the petitioner.

[Read Judgment]

Attachment
PDF
Vinith Narayan Nayak v. State of Karnataka
Preview
Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com