

The Karnataka High Court recently quashed criminal proceedings against a woman Traffic Police Sub-Inspector (SI) accused of allowing her son to drive her motorcycle, allegedly without a driver's licence, and perform stunts, resulting in the death of a pedestrian [Yasmeen Taj v. State of Karnataka].
In a judgment delivered on November 4, Justice Rajesh Rai K allowed a plea filed by Yasmeen Taj challenging the criminal proceedings initiated against her in connection with a fatal road accident reported in Nanjangud in September 2023.
“The petitioner, being the mother of accused No.1, cannot be prosecuted in a criminal trial only for the reason that she was the owner of the vehicle and mens rea (intent to commit a criminal offence) is very much required to attract criminal offence,” the Court observed.
The case concerned an incident from September 16, 2023, when a motorycle allegedly driven by Sayad Aiman hit a pedestrian, one Guruswamy.
The collision occurred when Aiman was allegedly performing a wheeling stunt using the bike. Guruswamy is said to have been sitting near an Asian Paints factory at Himmavu when the bike hit him. He was shifted to a hospital, where doctors declared him dead.
During the investigation, police found that the motorcycle was owned by Yasmeen Taj, the mother of the accused rider (Aiman). The police alleged that Taj, despite knowing that her son did not possess a valid driving license and had only a learner's license, handed over the motorcycle to him. The investigating officer consequently implicated her as the second accused, alleging that she contributed to the negligence resulting in the accident.
Taj eventually filed a plea before the High Court to quash the case against her. Advocate Sunil Kumar represented her in court and argued that the chargesheet itself made it clear that there was no material to establish that she had knowledge of her son's alleged act. It was also argued that the son was a major at the time of the incident and was holding a learner's license. Kumar maintained that Taj, therefore, could not be made criminally liable for an independent act of her adult son.
The State and the complainant countered that Taj knew that her son did not possess a valid driving license but nevertheless permitted him to use her motorcycle. They also alleged that the motorcycle was being used for wheeling without a number plate. The complainant's counsel further pointed to two previous FIRs registered against the accused driver (Taj's son) to contend that he was a habitual offender.
However, the Court found that since Taj had left for work on the day of the incident, and was neither present at the accident spot nor accompanying her son when the accident occurred, it could not be presumed that she knew her son had driven her bike and performed wheeling stunts on it.
"Since the petitioner left the house with accused No.1 for her duty, it cannot be presumed that she was well aware about accused No.1 taking the motorcycle and riding the same without a valid driving license and also the act of wheeling by accused No.1," it said.
The Court went on to hold that criminal liability could not be fastened on her merely because she was the mother of the accused rider and the registered owner of the motorcycle. The Court reasoned that the concept of vicarious liability (holding jointly someone guilty for an offence committed by another owing to a relationship shared between the two) is alien to criminal law.
"Merely because the petitioner is the mother of accused No.1, for the alleged act committed by accused No.1, she cannot be roped vicariously, since the vicarious liability is alien to criminal law," the Court held.
The Court concluded that the case against Taj was an abuse of the legal process and quashed the proceedings against her.
The Court, however, clarified that the complainant was at liberty to proceed against the necessary parties, including the motorcycle rider or even Taj, for compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act.
It added that the observations made in its order quashing the criminal case against Taj should not affect any compensation case filed before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal.
HCGP Mahesha P appeared for the State.
[Read Judgement]