Karnataka High Court stays probe against 10 more persons accused of attempting to delete Muslim voters through Form 7

The Court had earlier stayed such probe into two other cases. With today's order, the Court has effectively stayed probe into 5 cases.
SIR and Karnataka HC
SIR and Karnataka HC
Published on: 
4 min read

The Karnataka High Court on Tuesday stayed the probe in 3 first information reports (FIRs) against 10 persons accused of fraudulent use of Form 7 applications to delete Muslim voters from electoral rolls during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter rolls in the State.

The Court had earlier stayed such probe into two other cases. With today's order, the Court has effectively stayed probe into 5 cases.

Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde also deferred consideration of the State government's applications seeking vacation of the interim stay orders granted on October 9 in the petitions filed by GS Vasantha Lakshmi and Deepak Singh R.

The Court further directed the Election Commission of India (ECI) to place on record the materials relating to the decisions taken on the Form 7 applications, observing that the statutory inquiry into their correctness under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, should first run its course.

Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde
Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde

The cases arose from complaints alleging that bulk Form 7 applications had been filed by furnishing incorrect information to remove the names of eligible voters from electoral rolls. Some complaints alleged that the exercise was directed against members of the Muslim community.

In one of the cases concerning the Malleshwaram Assembly constituency, the complainant alleged that 778 Form 7 applications had been filed across eight polling stations, targeting voters belonging to a minority community.

Another complaint concerning Jayanagar alleged that 5,698 applications had been submitted, including 4,327 in Gurrappanapalya ward. Other cases related to alleged applications concerning 136 voters in Yeshwanthpur, 64 voters in Kodagu and voters in Mysuru.

The complainants alleged that the applications contained false information, forged signatures or instances of impersonation and sought police investigation into the alleged offences.

Advocate General K Shashi Kiran Shetty
Advocate General K Shashi Kiran Shetty

The State opposed the petitions, submitting that the right to vote was an extremely valuable right in a democracy and that fake or forged applications could not be permitted under the guise of the SIR exercise.

Senior Advocate M Aruna Shyam
Senior Advocate M Aruna Shyam

The petitioners, however, contended that Booth Level Agents were entitled to file Form 7 objections on behalf of political parties and that the correctness of such applications had to be examined by the Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) under the prescribed statutory procedure.

Senior Advocate Vivek Subba Reddy
Senior Advocate Vivek Subba Reddy

The Court examined Rules 15 to 23 of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, which provide for scrutiny of claims and objections, inquiry, hearing of the persons concerned and a decision by the Registration Officer. The Rules also provide for an appellate remedy against such decisions.

“From the aforementioned provisions, it is evident that a comprehensive statutory scheme has been provided for the inclusion and deletion of names in the electoral roll,” the Court observed.

It also referred to Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, which provides for imprisonment of up to one year, fine, or both, for making a knowingly false written declaration in connection with the preparation, revision or correction of electoral rolls.

“Thus, the statutory scheme under the Rules, 1960 provides for scrutiny and inquiry into the correctness of the information furnished under Form No.7 and penal consequences in case of false information,” the Court said.

On the allegations of forged signatures, the Court observed that a mere difference in signatures would not, by itself, establish forgery at this stage.

The Registration Officer would have to ascertain whether the person named in the application had actually signed it. If the person admitted signing the forms but the signatures differed, an explanation could be sought. If the person denied signing them, the circumstances could warrant further examination.

The Court further held that if the Registration Officer found that the forms had been signed by the named applicants, the officer would have to examine the merits of the objections, hear the persons whose names were sought to be deleted and pass appropriate orders.

In the circumstances, the Court held that the statutory inquiry had to be completed before deciding whether further police investigation into the alleged offences was warranted.

“The finding of the Registration Officer may furnish materials to take a call whether the case is made out to quash the FIR or to direct the investigation into all or any of the offences,” the Court observed.

Accordingly, the Court continued the stay on further investigation in the Vasantha Lakshmi and Deepak Singh R cases and declined to grant the State's applications seeking vacation of the interim orders.

In the remaining three cases — Ramakrishna and another, U H Lokesh and others, and Harish Kumar C and others — the Court granted interim relief by staying further investigation in the respective FIRs.

The complainants were permitted to seek modification or vacation of the interim orders. The State was also permitted to seek modification after receiving the relevant records from the Election Commission.

Advocate BN Jagadeesh
Advocate BN Jagadeesh

Senior Advocates Aruna Shyam M and Vivek Subba Reddy, along with advocate K G Aiyappa, appeared for the petitioners. Advocate General K Shashi Kiran Shetty and State Public Prosecutors B N Jagadeesha appeared for the State. Advocate Shathabish Shivanna appeared for the complainants, while advocate S R Dodawad appeared for the Election Commission of India.

[Read Orders]

Attachment
PDF
Vasantha Lakshmi G S v. State of Karnataka
Preview
Attachment
PDF
Deepak Singh R v. State of Karnataka
Preview
Attachment
PDF
Harish Kumar C & other v. State of Karnataka
Preview
Attachment
PDF
Ramakrishna & another v. State of Karnataka
Preview
Attachment
PDF
U H Lokesh & others v. State of Karnataka
Preview
Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com