

The Karnataka High Court observed on Saturday that the revelations made by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in its investigation into alleged irregularities in recruitment examinations conducted by the Karnataka Public Service Commission (KPSC), if true, were shocking.
Justice M Nagaprasanna noted that the findings, if established, could have a chilling effect on recruitments conducted by the KPSC in the past as well as the present.
“The revelations in the investigation conducted by the Enforcement Directorate, if true, would have a chilling effect on the recruitment that has taken place in the Karnataka State Public Service Commission, past and present,” the Court observed.
Hence, it directed the special investigation team (SIT) constituted by it to register FIRs based on ED's recommendations.
The Court was considering the matter after the ED submitted its status report detailing alleged irregularities and malpractices in several examinations conducted by the KPSC.
The case concerns allegations relating to two KPSC recruitment processes — recruitment to 50 Industrial Extension Officer posts and 400 Veterinary Officer posts.
On September 21, the High Court had ordered the formation of a five-member SIT headed by senior IPS officer Alok Kumar to investigate the alleged irregularities. The State government later challenged the order before the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court allowed the State to suggest alternative officers to replace the SIT chief and another member.
Based on the suggestions, the High Court on November 2 nominated Additional Director General of Police (ADGP) R Hitendra as the new head of the SIT.
Subsequently, the ED informed the Court that it had shared information gathered during its investigation with the Special Investigation Team (SIT) under Section 66(2) of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) on November 19, a day before the hearing.
Taking note of the information shared by the ED, the Court said that it was incumbent upon the SIT to register cases arising out of the alleged offences.
“All those crimes, as found hereinabove, would shock the conscience of this Court or should shock the conscience of a common man who would participate in the recruitment process in any given recruitment year conducted by the Karnataka Public Service Commission,” the Court said.
The Court noted that the State government, through its November 4 order, had reconstituted the SIT and declared it to be a police station for the purpose of investigation under Section 2(1)(u) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).
The State Public Prosecutor BN Jagadeesha submitted that the information shared by the ED would be taken to its logical conclusion in accordance with law. However, he submitted that the SIT could not directly register the crimes and that the information would have to be routed through the jurisdictional police stations, where cases would first be registered before being transferred to the SIT.
The Court clarified that the government order constituting the SIT contemplated the transfer of all existing and future cases relating to the KPSC recruitment irregularities to the special team.
“All crimes that are pending before jurisdictional police stations concerning the issue, and all crimes that would be registered before any of the jurisdictional police stations concerning the issue of the KPSC, without brooking any delay, shall stand transferred to the SIT for the purpose of investigation,” the Court directed.
It further clarified that this would include the information shared by the ED under Section 66(2) of the PMLA.
“The information that is shared by the Enforcement Directorate under Section 66(2) shall be transmitted to the jurisdictional police for the procedural route to be registered as crimes therein, and those registered crimes shall be immediately transferred to the SIT without brooking any delay,” the Court ordered.
The Court also noted that the jurisdictional police, including Vidhana Soudha Police Station, where the other related cases have been registered, would have to register the cognisable offences disclosed in the information shared by the ED and transfer the cases to the SIT for investigation.
Special Public Prosecutor Madhu N Rao appeared for the Enforcement Directorate.
Advocates Venkatesh Dalawai and Girish Bharadwaj appeared for the petitioners.