Painful but not contempt: Calcutta High Court on tweets by Abhishek Banerjee about court

The Court added that the tweets were not grounds to deny Banerjee an extension of interim protection in a criminal case pending against him over his remarks against Union Home Minister Amit Shah.
Abhishek Banerjee
Abhishek Banerjee
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

The Calcutta High Court on Friday said that the recent tweets posted by Trinamool Congress (TMC) leader Abhishek Banerjee criticising the Court, though painful, did not appear to be contemptuous or grounds to deny him an extension of interim protection in a criminal case.

Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya proceeded to extend interim protection earlier granted to Banerjee in a criminal case pending against him over remarks allegedly targeting Union Home Minister Amit Shah.

The interim protection has been extended till January 29, 2027.

 Justice Saugata bhattacharya
Justice Saugata bhattacharya

When the matter was heard today, Additional Advocate General Rajdeep Mazumder told the Court that Banerjee has posted tweets in which he made derogatory remarks against the judiciary. The exact content of the tweets was not discussed.

"He (Banerjee) is repeatedly attacking the High Court and the Judiciary," the AAG said.

The Court opined that tweets, while painful, did not appear to be contemptuous. It added that these tweets could not be a reason to refuse Banerjee an extension of interim protection, particularly when the TMC leader has been cooperating with the investigation.

"Is it wilful, deliberate, contumacious contempt? Can a tweet be the basis for contumacious contempt? Can it be a ground to refuse interim prayer? Where is the change in circumstances denying a change in the nature of the interim order?" Justice Bhattacharya remarked.

The Court, however, expressed anguish about Banerjee's comments against it.

"Derogatory comments have been made about the Court, what message does it convey to his followers? The Court finds these comments are not willful, deliberate and contumacious contempt, though the comments are painful. Why is he (Banerjee) harming his position?" the Court asked.

Banerjee's counsel, meanwhile, said that he was unaware of any derogatory tweets made by Banerjee but would look into the circumstances.

Derogatory comments have been made about the Court, what message does it convey to his followers? The Court finds these comments are not willful, deliberate and contumacious contempt, though the comments are painful.
Calcutta High Court

The Court recorded that Banerjee's remarks/ tweets need not be discussed at this stage. It further noted that there was nothing yet to indicate that Banerjee has not cooperated with the ongoing probe to deny him an extension of interim protection.

The Court was dealing with a plea moved by Banerjee to quash a criminal case registered against him over comments he made at election rallies in the run up to the recently concluded West Bengal Legislative Assembly elections.

The complainant accused Banerjee of making provocative speeches targeting opposition party workers and threatening BJP leader and Union Home Minister Amit Shah. Banerjee is reported to have said at an April 7 roadshow, 

"I will see who comes to save them on May 4. I will see which godfather (allegedly referring to Amit Shah) from Delhi comes to their rescue." 

The Court had earlier criticised the alleged comments, terming them irresponsible and unnecessary. However, by its May 21 order, the Court granted Banerjee interim protection from any coercive action, provided he cooperates with the ongoing investigation.

The said interim protection has been extended from time to time. Today, the said interim relief was extended till January 29 next year.

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com