Penalising conduct once considered immoral will now amount to moral policing: Madras High Court

The Court modified the dismissal of a government nurse over her relationship with a married man.
Madras High Court
Madras High Court
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

Societal attitude towards marital relationships and childbirth has undergone changes and scrutinising or penalising conduct, once considered immoral and socially unacceptable, would now amount to moral policing, the Madras High Court recently observed.

A Division Bench of Justice G Jayachandran and Justice E Manoharan made the observation while modifying the punishment imposed on a government nurse who was dismissed from service for having a child with a married man.

"In yesteryears, certain conduct which were neither legally nor morally right and considered as a stigmatic behavior, has changed. In recent days they are either decriminalized or termed as ‘moral policing'," the Court said.

The Bench consequently modified the nurse's punishment from dismissal to removal from service, leaving open the possibility of her reappointment. However, it upheld the disciplinary finding that her conduct amounted to moral turpitude under the Tamil Nadu Government Servants' Conduct Rules, 1973.

Justice G Jayachandran and Justice E Manoharan
Justice G Jayachandran and Justice E Manoharan

The case concerned a staff nurse working at a government hospital in Kancheepuram district.

She initially joined government service on a contractual basis in 2007, and her services were regularised in July 2009.

Disciplinary proceedings were initiated against her following a complaint by the wife of a man with whom the nurse allegedly had a relationship and a child.

The provision prohibits government employees from engaging in acts involving moral turpitude, including unlawful conduct that may embarrass or bring discredit to the government.

The nurse challenged her dismissal before the High Court, arguing that her personal relationship did not amount to misconduct.

She maintained that there was no proof of a marriage between her and the man concerned and that having a child with a person to whom she was not married could not, by itself, constitute moral turpitude.

Her counsel also pointed out that the criminal proceedings initiated against her had ultimately ended in acquittal.

The Court noted that the nurse had initially been convicted by a magistrate for abetting bigamy and sentenced to two years' rigorous imprisonment.

However, during the criminal appeal, the parties reached a compromise under which the complainant agreed to receive ₹10 lakh in instalments and withdraw the complaint. The appellate court subsequently permitted compounding of the offence and acquitted the nurse.

The High Court held that the subsequent acquittal did not erase the misconduct established during the disciplinary proceedings.

"This will only help her to avoid undergoing the sentence, but this will not wipe out the moral turpitude which has embarrassed the Government so as to invoke Rule 19(2) of the Conduct Rules," the Bench observed.

It consequently agreed with the single-judge's decision to uphold the disciplinary action.

However, the Bench considered the nurse's alternative request for a lesser punishment, particularly in light of the subsequent compromise and dissolution of the marriage between the man and the complainant.

The Court held that the original punishment was not disproportionate when assessed against the facts and law prevailing at the time of the disciplinary proceedings.

Nevertheless, taking note of changing societal attitudes, it modified the punishment from dismissal to removal from service.

The Bench suggested that the government could consider an application from the nurse for reinstatement without past service benefits or for a fresh appointment, provided she was otherwise eligible.

It clarified that this was only a suggestion and not a binding direction to the authorities.

The appeal was accordingly disposed off on November 12.

Advocate Balan Haridas appeared for the nurse.

Government Advocate K Rajesh represented the State authorities.

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com