

The Supreme Court’s one-time permission to light the Karthigai Deepam at a disputed stone pillar on Thiruparankundram hill effectively gave the writ petitioners the final relief they sought for this year, Tamil Nadu’s Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Commissioner has argued in a review petition.
The Commissioner said a Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi had allowed the ceremony without finding even a prima facie right to light the lamp at the pillar.
“The interim arrangement grants to the writ petitioners, for the year 2026, precisely what they prayed for before the High Court, while the challenge carried by the State and the statutory authorities remains to be heard,” the review petition said.
On November 20, the Supreme Court stayed the Madras High Court’s findings on the nature of the pillar and the land on which it stands. It allowed only a temple-authorised team to light the lamp on November 24 and directed that worship at customary sites and lawful access to the dargah continue undisturbed
The appeals arose from a December 2025 order by Madras High Court Justice GR Swaminathan directing the temple to light the lamp at the pillar in addition to the customary site.
A Division Bench upheld that direction in January 2026 and held that the pillar stood on temple land. The Supreme Court is due to hear the main appeals further in January 2027.
The Commissioner sought an ex parte stay of the November 20 directions permitting the ceremony. The plea said the review would become infructuous once the lamp was lit, since a later order could not undo the ceremony. It also sought an open-court hearing and asked the Court to bar lighting at the pillar until it decides the main appeals.
The State argued that withholding permission would leave the festival intact because the lamp could still be lit at its customary location near the Uchippillaiyar Temple. Allowing the ceremony at the disputed pillar near the Sikandar Badusha Dargah, it said, could disturb communal harmony and be seen as vindicating the claim of custom, even with the Court’s clarification that the permission could not be relied on in future years.
The Commissioner further argued that the Court had overlooked the statutory scheme for deciding disputes over temple usage. Under Section 28(1) of the Tamil Nadu HR&CE Act, the trustee must administer the temple in accordance with its established usage. Section 63(e), the plea said, empowers the Joint Commissioner to determine that usage after examining evidence.
The petition also cited a 1996 Madras High Court order under which, according to the State, the lamp was ordinarily to be lit near the Uchippillaiyar Temple. The State said any decision to change the location rested with the temple administration, subject to prior permission from the statutory authorities.