West Bengal moves Supreme Court against Calcutta HC order barring KMC elections based on redrawn wards

The High Court ordered that elections should not be held on the basis of the amended Schedule II of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation Act until a petition challenging the validity of the delimitation exercise is decided.
West Bengal state
West Bengal state
Published on: 
2 min read
Listen to this article

The West Bengal government has moved the Supreme Court challenging a Calcutta High Court order restraining the State Election Commission from notifying elections to the Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) based on a delimitation notification issued in September that proposes to increase the number of civic wards in KMC from 144 to 209.

A Division Bench of Justices Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya and Arjun Ray Mukherjee had on November 6 ordered that no election notification should be issued on the basis of the amended Schedule II of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation Act, 1980, until a pending petition challenging the validity of the delimitation exercise is decided.

The High Court order was passed on an appeal filed by Dipu Das, a former ward councillor under the Communist Party of India (Marxist) [CPI(M)] regime between 2005 and 2010.

The dispute stemmed from a September 11 notification altering the boundaries of municipal wards ahead of the civic elections.

Das alleged that the exercise amounted to gerrymandering intended to secure political advantage for the ruling party. It was also contended that the exercise relied on electoral rolls rather than actual population figures.

The central question before the High Court was whether an administrator appointed by the State government following the dissolution of the elected Corporation could recommend changes to municipal ward boundaries under Section 601 of the KMC Act.

The High Court found that the statutory power to make such recommendations belonged to the Corporation as an elected institution and could not be exercised by an administrator appointed to discharge its temporary administrative functions.

It observed that permitting such an arrangement would effectively allow the State government to make a recommendation to itself through its appointed Administrator.

The High Court also examined whether Article 243ZG of the Constitution, which restricts judicial interference in certain municipal electoral matters, barred the challenge.

It held that the constitutional restriction did not apply to the exercise under consideration, which involved an executive notification issued under Section 601 of the KMC Act.

The Court further examined the sequence of events preceding the notification and expressed concerns about possible arbitrariness. However, it clarified that allegations of malice in law and gerrymandering required adjudication and could not be conclusively determined at the interim stage.

The High Court consequently modified a single-judge's order and restrained the State Election Commission from notifying elections on the basis of the revised ward boundaries until the petition is disposed of.

The State government has now challenged that interim order before the Supreme Court.

The petition before the Supreme Court was filed on November 13 through advocate Uddyam Mukherjee.

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com