Madras High Court grants interim relief to couple who received copyright notice over music at their wedding

The Court on November 5 restrained the copyright firm from disrupting the couple’s November 15 wedding-related cocktail event and dinner.
Madras High Court
Madras High Court
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

A copyright licensing firm’s demand for fees to play music at a private wedding-related cocktail event recently prompted a Chennai-based lawyer and his fiancé to approach the Madras High Court seeking protection from such copyright infringement threats.

On November 5, Justice PB Balaji granted the couple interim protection and restrained the copyright licence firm - Novex Communications Pvt Ltd - from disrupting the couple’s November 15 wedding-related cocktail event and dinner, held at Chennai’s Taj Connemara hotel.

“If such an interim order is not made, the applicants/plaintiffs would be put to irreparable loss, if the first respondent attempts to interfere with the cocktail event, followed by dinner, by creating any chaos or commotion by arriving at the event, in the presence of the guests of the applicants/plaintiffs and creating untoward incidents at the event, thereby disturbing the smooth conduct of the cocktail event followed by dinner, thereby resulting in great embarrassment for the applicants/plaintiffs. In the light of the above, there will be an order of interim injunction as prayed for,” the Court said. 

Justice PB Balaji
Justice PB Balaji

The couple told the Court that they were planning to host a cocktail event, followed by dinner at the hotel's ballroom in the evening, as part of their wedding celebrations.

Their counsel submitted that they had also obtained a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Indian Performing Right Society (which does not charge any fee for the issue of NOC) for the use of music licensed to it.

However, on October 27, Novex sent a communication to the hotel stating that the playing music at the event would amount to a violation of Novex’s copyrights. The communication added that consent would have to first be obtained from Novex and the necessary licence fee paid before music can be played at the event.

This prompted the couple to approach the High Court, seeking a declaration that the copyright infringement threats issued by Novex were groundless. They also sought directions to permanently restrain the firm from issuing any such demands. 

As interim relief, the couple urged the Court to restrain Novex or its representatives from disturbing the November 15 event, lingering near the venue or doing any act that could disrupt the event or inconvenience guests. 

They pointed out that Section 52(1)(za) of the Copyright Act of 1957 lays down that playing copyrighted music without a licence at religious ceremonies and associated marriage festivities would not constitute copyright infringement. Their counsel pointed out that the cocktail event and dinner, in this case, is linked to the couple’s marriage and would be clearly covered by Section 52(1)(za).

They also told the Court that they were unaware of how Novex’s copyrights would be infringed or which music played at the event comprised music that the firm held copyrights to. The couple explained that they had hired an event manager to coordinate the event.

The Court observed that the larger question of whether playing songs licensed to Novex would amount to copyright infringement could be examined at a later stage. If Novex is found to be a valid licence holder and entitled to be paid a licence fee, it can always be compensated monetarily later, the Court noted. 

In the meanwhile, however, the couple should not be subjected to inconvenience, prejudice or embarrassment on their wedding day, the Court said. 

Therefore, it proceeded to pass an interim injunction order in the couple’s favour, restraining Novex or its representatives from disturbing the event.

However, the larger question of whether Novex is entitled to licence fees for the music played at the wedding event remains pending. 

The matter will be heard next on December 3. 

Advocates Sathish Kumar K Seshasayee represented the plaintiffs.

[Read Order]

Attachment
PDF
B Karthiyani, and anr v. Novex-2
Preview
Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com