

The Bombay High Court on Thursday criticised the people of Mumbai for flouting restrictions on bursting of firecrackers during Diwali and also flagged the conduct of people encouraging others to burst crackers [In re: Noise and Environmental Pollution].
A division bench of Justices GS Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale expressed serious concern over severe post-Diwali air and noise pollution and cited news reports of over 330 fire incidents caused by stray rockets striking high-rises and Air Quality Index (AQI) levels breaching 400.
“People appear to have no consciousness for the societal cause. People are really insensitive. Why every time the court is required to say? Why don't we improve our habits?” the bench remarked.
The Court said that the police and municipal machinery were helpless and cannot be faulted when people willingly indulge in such violations.
"Police are totally helpless; they did their best. The municipal machinery also did their best. But ultimately it is totally beyond control."
Justice Gokhale flagged instance of people on social media encouraging others to burst crackers.
“Social media, if you see, is replete with instances where people are actually encouraging others to burn firecrackers for whatever reasons,” she observed.
The Court made the observation while reserving its order in the case concerning air pollution and imposition of a complete ban on the sale and bursting of firecrackers across Maharashtra
The bench observed that existing restrictions had failed to prevent widespread violations by people, with firecrackers being burst until 4 am across Mumbai.
Amicus Curiae Anand Pai said there should a total halt on firecracker sales until authorities designate regulated community firework grounds.
Advocate Rohaan Cama, appearing for petitioners, presented test data showing that half of sampled green crackers carried fake QR codes and contained banned barium.
The counsel for the Mumbai and Thane District Fireworks Dealers Welfare Association opposed a blanket ban, arguing licensed traders were being penalized for illegal vendors.
The bench cited Supreme Court orders which ruled that trade rights under Article 19(1)(g) remain subservient to the right to life under Article 21.
"You may have a right to do business, but not to harm the lives of the people," the judges told retailers.
They also clarified that hazardous practices also enjoy no protection under Article 25.
The bench also equated stray rockets to residential intrusions.
"Would you let somebody enter the flat and burn firecrackers inside the house? It is as bad as that. You can't have celebrations that you're going to damage somebody's property like this," the Court remarked.
“Everybody cannot afford to have these big air purifiers at home,” the bench added.
Before reserving its order, the court indicated that any forthcoming directions would apply across Maharashtra rather than urban centres alone.