

Supreme Court judge Justice Joymalya Bagchi on Saturday proposed the establishment of round-the-clock artificial intelligence (AI) courts to deal with mutual consent divorce cases, saying routine judicial work should be shifted away from human judges.
Justice Bagchi was speaking at the Just Tech National Conclave organised by Dharmashastra National Law University at Jabalpur on the role of AI and technology in the administration of justice.
"We should, in my understanding, hive off the mutual divorce cases and have 24/7 AI divorce courts so that there will be ease of access to justice and no wastage of valuable human resources on completely non-adjudicatory exercises," he said.
Justice Bagchi said the judiciary's mounting pendency necessitates technological intervention and use of AI tools.
"We are sitting on a pile of over five crore cases. And with the given infrastructure and human resources, we are not going to go anywhere near delivering quick, efficient and timely justice until and unless we have transformative interventions through artificial intelligence tool deployments," he said.
The judge advocated transferring routine and predictable cases, governed by established legal principles, from human judges to AI adjudication. He said applications seeking early hearings before the Supreme Court and High Courts should also be handled through AI systems rather than judges.
"This should be completely taken away from the human agency," he said.
Justice Bagchi suggested developing AI tools that could assess case pendency, optimal disposal timelines, age and other relevant considerations, including cases involving women, before deciding early hearing requests.
He also proposed using AI for procedural directions concerning filing of affidavits, extensions of time and preparation of cases for hearing.
Turning to substantive disputes, Justice Bagchi suggested AI-generated predictive verdicts in cheque dishonour cases, land acquisition matters and commercial disputes involving recovery of money.
"Let the argument start from there," he said, adding that predictive outcomes could be made available to judges before the commencement of arguments.
However, he cautioned against allowing AI to displace human reasoning in constitutional adjudication. Referring to landmark judgments including Kesavananda Bharati, Maneka Gandhi and Marbury v. Madison, he said such developments in constitutional law require human judicial ingenuity.
"So the human agency must be preserved as the most precious virtue and the tool of adjudication," Justice Bagchi said.
He maintained that AI should reduce the burden of routine judicial work while preserving human judges for matters requiring substantive adjudication.
[Read Live Coverage]