Court model 
Columns

Take the writ to the district court: An alternative to regional Supreme Court benches

Whether a person is held without lawful authority is a question of fact that a properly empowered district court can determine.

Prasanth Raju

On November 4, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister C Joseph Vijay wrote to the Prime Minister seeking a Supreme Court Bench in Chennai, because access under Article 32 has become practically difficult for those far from Delhi.

Six days later, Union Minister of State for Law and Justice Arjun Ram Meghwal said that evening courts, sitting beyond regular hours, would be piloted in Delhi, Bihar and Andhra Pradesh. A provision of the Constitution joins them and Parliament has left it unused for 76 years.

The central question is whether the Chief Minister's objective can be met without the consent of the Supreme Court. The demand for a Bench is well supported, with the Law Commission's 95th, 125th and 229th Reports and the Parliamentary Standing Committee's 2nd, 6th, 15th, 20th and 133rd Reports among those favouring regional benches. Its difficulty is constitutional. Under Article 130, the Chief Justice of India appoints other places of sitting with the approval of the President. The Full Court rejected the proposal in August 2007 and reiterated its position in February 2010. A 2016 reference to a Constitution Bench is still pending. The Prime Minister cannot grant what the letter seeks.

Article 32(3) offers a route that does not depend on that consent. Structurally, it has three components. First, parliament may by law empower “any other court” to exercise the Supreme Court's powers under clause (2), which are the powers to issue writs for the enforcement of fundamental rights. Second, the court acts only “within the local limits of its jurisdiction”. Third, the powers may be conferred in part, since the words are “all or any”. Article 35 reserves such a law to Parliament. The jurisdiction would, therefore, concern Part III, chiefly Article 21. It would not replicate the wider jurisdiction of the High Courts under Article 226. Parliament has made no such law.

The history is instructive. In the Constituent Assembly on December 9, 1948, Naziruddin Ahmad asked why a poor litigant should be driven to the Supreme Court. Dr BR Ambedkar replied, “See sub-clause (3).” Rohini Kumar Chaudhuri welcomed the clause for distant places such as Assam and Coorg, while urging that it be used sparingly.

Makhan Singh (1964) holds that clause (3) merely confers the Court's powers under clause (2); the guarantee in clause (1) cannot be claimed in respect of other courts. L Chandra Kumar (1997) refers to clause (3) in holding that other forums may supplement, but not exclude, the jurisdiction of the High Courts and the Supreme Court. Any district jurisdiction must, therefore, remain supplementary.

Other systems have distributed writ jurisdiction across levels of their judicial hierarchies, though not identically. Nepal's Administration of Justice Act, 2016 empowers each district court to issue habeas corpus to enforce the legal rights of a person unlawfully detained in the district, a wider formulation than Article 32(3) permits. Sri Lanka's Thirteenth Amendment gave its provincial high courts habeas corpus for persons illegally detained within the province, but tied their other writs to the provincial council list. Kenya's Magistrates' Courts Act, 2015 confines magistrates to the rights against torture and slavery. Bangladesh's Article 44(2) reproduces India’s clause. The United States offers a statutory analogy: mandamus against federal officers lay in the District of Columbia alone until Congress, by what is now 28 USC 1361, extended it in 1962 to every federal district court. The lesson is to begin with habeas corpus.

The case for habeas corpus rests on delay. Of 7,448 preventive detention judgments of the Madras High Court from 2000 to January 2022, a study found that 6,547 were set aside. Petitions took 141 days on average from filing and by the time of decision, the detenu had spent about 181 days in custody, since detention precedes filing. A remedy that succeeds in nearly nine cases of ten, but only after six months of custody, protects the right in form, not in substance. The average district headquarters lies 152 km in a straight line from the High Court seat or bench with jurisdiction over it. A Chennai Bench would bring the Supreme Court closer to litigants across the State, but would leave the remedy distant from a person detained in a remote district. Questions on the validity of legislation should remain with the High Courts. Whether a person is held without lawful authority is a question of fact that a properly empowered district court can determine.

Two objections remain: capacity and independence. On December 31, 2025, 4,855 of 25,886 posts in district and subordinate courts were vacant, against 4.76 crore pending cases. Vidhi's 2019 survey of 665 court complexes found fully functioning washrooms in only 40 per cent. The constitutional proposition does not depend on evening courts and the pilot as announced does not provide for a habeas roster; it is an opportunity to adapt. Unlawful custody does not keep court hours and a serving district judge designated by the High Court could take a dedicated evening roster. Unlike a retired judge engaged for evening sittings, a serving officer's posting, transfer and discipline remain with the High Court under Articles 233 and 235. The statute must also give him enforceable powers to secure production and punish disobedience, since the writ would run against the Collector and the Superintendent of Police.

The first statute should, therefore, be modest, as “all or any” permits. It should confer habeas corpus alone, in pilot districts farthest from a High Court; require production within 24 hours of the court's order and a decision within seven days, extendable only by a reasoned order; provide one appeal to the High Court, with no automatic stay of release; and leave Articles 32, 226 and 227 untouched. Tamil Nadu cannot enact it, but its State Law Commission can draft the Bill and its Assembly and members of parliament can press for it. The Commission can separately recommend that the Madras High Court consider expedited timelines for habeas corpus proceedings under its rule-making powers.

A Chennai Bench may bring the Supreme Court closer; an Act of Parliament can bring the remedy closer still. For a person held in a taluk lock-up, the nearest court may be the most meaningful one. The present circumstances make it imperative that Parliament exercise the constitutional power it has possessed since 1950.

Prasanth Raju is an advocate of the Bombay High Court.

Foreigners accused of visa overstay can't be kept in detention centres after getting bail: Delhi High Court

Come to Delhi from Singapore only after AQI improves: Supreme Court's candid advice for litigant

Thiruparankundram lamp lighting: Dargah committee says Madras High Court judge inspected site before making them a party to case

Supreme Court orders search for World War II veteran's heirs after Centre alleges possible fraud in pension claim

Madras High Court refuses to lift construction freeze around Pallikaranai marshland

SCROLL FOR NEXT