

The Supreme Court was on Wednesday told that Madras High Court Justice GR Swaminathan had inspected the disputed site at Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai without notifying the Dargah Committee before passing an order permitting the lighting of Karthigai Deepam at a stone pillar near the Dargah.
A Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi was hearing appeals challenging the Madras High Court's ruling concerning where the Karthigai Deepam should be lit in Thiruparankundram.
The dispute arose after the Thiruparankundram Subramaniya Swamy Temple administration rejected a devotee’s request to light Karthigai Deepam at a stone pillar near the Sikandar Badusha Dargah.
In December 2025, a single judge bench of Justice Swaminathan directed additional lamp-lighting there. A division bench upheld the direction in January 2026, prompting appeals before the Supreme Court.
Appearing for the Dargah Committee today, Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi argued that Justice Swaminathan had conducted the inspection on November 19, 2025, the same day the Dargah was impleaded in the writ proceedings.
"In my respectful submission, My Lords, ordinarily a writ court, a constitutional court, does not, My Lords, conduct private inspection," Ahmadi submitted.
He argued that while civil courts sometimes conducted inspections to identify disputed properties, the inspection by a High Court judge was extraordinary because the affected party had not been notified.
According to Ahmadi, the Dargah was impleaded suo motu on November 19, but received private notice only on November 20. The Court issued notice on November 21, following which the Committee entered appearance on November 24. A preliminary counter-affidavit was filed on November 28, when the single judge also reserved judgment. The decision was pronounced on December 1, 2025.
Ahmadi contended that the Committee had not been given adequate opportunity to present its case. He particularly questioned the single judge's finding that the disputed Deepathoon was situated on an unoccupied portion of the hill belonging exclusively to the temple.
"These findings, My Lords, would not have been returned if we were given notice, if we were able to assist the learned judge at the site," he submitted.
Ahmadi argued that the Dargah could have demonstrated that the disputed pillar was located between Nallitope, an area recognised as belonging to Muslim parties under an earlier civil court decree, and the summit containing the Dargah.
He further submitted that the High Court had incorrectly interpreted a 1923 civil court decree, subsequently restored by the Privy Council, concerning ownership of the hill. According to Ahmadi, the decree recognised the rights of Muslim parties over the whole hillock on which the Dargah stood, besides Nallitope and the steps leading to the mosque.
However, the High Court had concluded that the disputed pillar stood on temple land.
"The expression 'whole of the hillock' has been changed only to 'just Dargah'. The decree uses the expression 'the whole of the hillock'," Ahmadi argued.
He submitted that any dispute over the extent of ownership recognised under the decree ought to be resolved through properly constituted civil proceedings rather than a writ petition.
The Committee also argued that the Division Bench had acknowledged its grievance concerning inadequate opportunity before the Single Judge but treated the subsequent appellate hearing as sufficient.
Meanwhile, Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for the Madurai District Collector, argued that historical records relating to the Great Trigonometrical Survey supported the State's position that the disputed structure was a survey marker rather than a religious lamp pillar.
He referred to survey descriptions identifying a station near the mosque and submitted that the single judge had not been provided these materials. Sankaranarayanan, however, acknowledged that an 1890 publication containing similar information had been produced by a private party before the Division Bench. He conceded that State authorities had been unable to confirm the information at that stage.
"The State authorities said that 'we don't know what that pillar is'," he submitted, adding that the State was now confirming the information placed earlier by the private party.
Sankaranarayanan argued that the High Court's identification of the structure as a Deepathoon rested substantially on its physical appearance, without adequate consideration of its possible surveying purpose. He also expressed concern that recognising religious significance in such structures could encourage similar claims elsewhere.
"Our fear as the State is that if this were to start happening—that this judgment remains undisturbed—then all these pillars will suddenly get a religious colour," he submitted.
At this stage, the Bench questioned the Collector's submissions in light of the earlier civil court decree concerning ownership of the hill. The Bench observed that the decree recognised the land as belonging to the Hindu parties, except for certain portions belonging to the Muslim parties.
"According to the decree, this land belongs to the Hindu temple land. Nobody is doubting that either?" the Bench questioned.
Sankaranarayanan said that the State was not disputing this position.
The Bench then asked whether the Collector was asserting ownership over the disputed land.
Sankaranarayanan replied that the question of the State's ownership had not arisen in the proceedings and that he could not provide an answer without obtaining instructions.
"I don't think as State we are asserting ownership to this land," he said.
The Bench then questioned whether the Collector could continue advancing arguments concerning the structure's historical use if the State was not asserting ownership.
"All your argument that this is a boundary wall, and this was used for a meridian, checking the compass and a straight line, and all this goes," the Bench remarked.
When Sankaranarayanan attempted to explain the relevance of the survey, the Bench responded,
"Then you cannot canvas all this!"
Sankaranarayanan maintained that the survey evidence remained relevant and sought to illustrate his argument by referring to a telecom tower depicted in the materials placed before the Court.
On the question of religious practice, Sankaranarayanan submitted that the Karthigai Deepam had traditionally been lit near the Uchippillaiyar temple.
The Bench clarified during the hearing that it was considering only interim relief and not finally deciding the dispute.
The hearing will continue on November 19 at 2 PM, with the Court fixing time limits for the remaining submissions.