During a recent board meeting, a significant related party transaction was scrutinized and subsequently approved. Two years later, this transaction is now subject to investigation by regulatory authorities.
Independent directors often perceive Section 149(12) of the Companies Act, 2013 as a safeguard against personal liability. As they are typically not involved in the management or daily operations of the company, this provision limits their liability to matters they were aware of through Board discussions that they either supported or contributed to or in cases where their due diligence was insufficient. However, the necessity for diligence fundamentally alters the interpretation of this provision; it necessitates tangible evidence of actions taken rather than merely serving an honorary capacity upon appointment.
According to Section 149(6) of the Companies Act, 2013, a director qualifies as independent if they are neither managing nor nominee directors and if the board assesses them as honest with adequate experience and no ties to either the company or its promoters. For publicly traded companies, at least one-third of directors must be independent (Section 149(4)), which increases to fifty percent under Regulation 17(1)(b) of SEBI (LODR) Regulations, 2015 (“LODR”) when there is no regular non-executive chairperson affiliated with promoters.
The Code outlined in Schedule IV requires independent directors to provide external perspectives during board deliberations while ensuring that management is held accountable for decisions impacting minority shareholders' interests, effectively and thoroughly evaluating transactions involving related parties. This Code delineates significant responsibilities; failure to meet these obligations could jeopardize a director's ability to assert due diligence later on.
This section provides protection specifically for independent and non-executive directors who do not belong to categories such as promoters or key managerial personnel concerning defaults occurring within the company "with their knowledge," attributed via Board processes where consent or collusion was evident or situations characterized by negligence regarding due diligence (Section 149(12)). Pertaining to listed entities, Regulation 25(5) from LODR reinforces this stipulation; additionally, as per Section 2(60), any director receiving materials from Board meetings without objection assumes awareness regarding any violations discussed therein.
The ruling in SMS Pharmaceuticals Ltd v Neeta Bhalla [(2005)8 SCC89] clarified that mere appointment does not suffice; complaints must demonstrate active involvement in business operations at times misconduct occurred.
Similarly in Shailendra Swarup v Deputy Director Enforcement Directorate [2020 SCC OnLine SC600], reflecting findings from SMS Pharmaceuticals, the Supreme Court assessed actual contributions rather than nominal titles overturning penalties imposed under FERA's Section 68 based on these evaluations.
In cases like KS Mehta v Morgan Securities and Credits Pvt Ltd [2025 SCC OnLine SC492], allegations surrounding cheque dishonor against both non-executive and independent directors were dismissed due to a lack of clarity about transactional roles.
The Delhi High Court's decision in Praveen Singh v Religare Finvest (P) Ltd. [20255 Online Del10832] also referenced Section 149(12), resulting in the dismissal of summons against a non-executive director based on similar reasoning.
A recurring theme throughout these judgments is that directors prevailed when confronted with vague accusations or unclear positions.
1. Adopt Proactive Measures: Review all pertinent documents prior to meetings and ask relevant questions regarding critical issues; ensure every discussion including dissent is accurately recorded in the minutes since unrecorded objections may be difficult to substantiate later.
2. Lead Audit Committees: Two-thirds membership requirements mandate independence among audit committees including chairs (Regulation 18 of LODR). Scrutinize accounting estimates alongside auditor qualifications before presentations; conduct thorough evaluations around oversight systems while examining inter-company loans/investments plus CFO appointments (as outlined in Sections177[4]and Part C Schedule II).
3. Examine Related Party Transactions: Only those deemed independent within audit committees shall authorize such transactions (Regulations 23[2]). Request minimal information before voting on related party matters according to SEBI standards confirming assertions regarding arm’s length transactions while ensuring materiality thresholds established under Schedule XII, all justifications for decisions must be documented.
4. Oversee Major Transactions: Under SEBI guidelines, substantial responsibilities rest upon independent directors to guarantee major transactions such as merger or demerger or any fund raising activity benefit shareholders via an independently formed committee providing reasoned recommendations for open offers, preferential issuances scaling control should also receive their support (Regulation 166A ICDR Regulations). Conduct diligent reviews around valuation assessments while monitoring fund utilization through audit committees (Regulation 32 of LODR).
5. Protect Sensitive Information: As designated individuals outlined by SEBI's insider trading regulations framework, it becomes imperative for external board members to adhere to trading windows along with following clearance protocols prior trading activities outside scheduled intervals.
6. Recognize When Resignation Is Necessary: Should circumstances demand it, resign your position providing material reasons documented through Form DIR-11, the company will then need file DIR-12 accordingly.
7. Ensure Adequate Coverage and Training: Familiarize yourself with Directors’ and Officers' insurance policies mandated for top-tier listed entities (regulatory framework 25{10}) lodged through assessment limits coverage specifically applicable during investigatory inquiries, including exclusions plus run-off coverage after departure.
The related party transaction now under investigation will test one thing: the record. Section 149(12) and the case law favour directors who can show diligent inquiry (papers read, questions asked and action taken all minuted). There is no safe harbour for those who do not practice that diligence consistently and meet the standards the law sets; a title only provides illusory comfort; without a documentary trail, there is little to defend. The record is the anchor that holds.
About the author: Abhishekh Kanoi is the Group General Counsel & Company Secretary at PDS Limited.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s). The opinions presented do not necessarily reflect the views of Bar & Bench.
If you would like your Deals, Columns, Press Releases to be published on Bar & Bench, please fill in the form available here.