Prabhakaran S, Shubhangi Bhargava, Jonathan Rodrigues 
The Viewpoint

Lenders and borrowers: Ad-hoc is out; institutional ODR is in

Lenders should replace vulnerable ad-hoc arbitration with independent institutional online dispute resolution, which can make loan disputes fairer, more transparent, and efficient.

Prabhakaran S, Shubhangi Bhargava, Jonathan Rodrigues

Banks and NBFCs were accustomed to engaging in ad-hoc arbitration to recover loan defaults instead of lengthy court proceedings. This model is now facing serious challenges, as unilateral appointment of arbitrators by lenders has come under repeated scrutiny from courts. With awards increasingly being challenged on grounds of appointment, independence and procedural fairness, lenders and borrowers are finding themselves back in litigation, defending or challenging the arbitration awards. For parties, challenged awards mean fresh proceedings, additional costs, lost time and possible limitation disputes, and deterioration of trust in ad-hoc arbitration.

The way forward for the lending industry lies in Institutional ODR (Online Dispute Resolution). Technology enables the institution to manage the entire process online, from case allocation and issuance of notices to document management, appointment of arbitrator, hearings and communication with parties. Neither party controls the appointment of the individual arbitrator, and the institution oversees the proceedings through a pre-defined process agreed by parties.

This brings greater independence, transparency and procedural consistency to arbitration, thus enhancing trust in the process. Institutional ODR extends beyond lending to sectors such as securities, insurance, e-commerce, MSMEs and consumer services, offering organisations an efficient and scalable mechanism for dispute resolution.

What do the courts say on unilateral appointment

For years, many loan agreements allowed the lender to appoint an ad-hoc arbitrator. The lender chose the person who would adjudicate the dispute. The Supreme Court restricted such appointments in TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering (2017) and Perkins Eastman v. HSCC (2019). In November 2024, a five judge bench at the Supreme Court went further in CORE v. ECI SPIC SMO MCML stating that a party interested in the outcome cannot appoint the sole arbitrator or require the other party to choose from a panel it has drawn up.

Even if a borrower has signed a loan agreement allowing the lender to appoint the arbitrator, this prior consent is not sufficient under the law. Section 12(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, overrides such prior agreements. Such agreements can be valid when the borrower provides consent in an explicitly written acceptance to the appointed arbitrator, after the dispute has risen.

In September 2026, in Shikha Ghosh v. Axis Bank Ltd., where a borrower challenged an award passed without hearing her by an arbitrator appointed by the bank, the Delhi High Court decided against the lender. The bank admitted that the same arbitrator had decided 4,155 of its cases in about five years, and told the court that around 76,000 awards had been passed in its own cases across India by such sole arbitrators. The Delhi High Court declared the award as unenforceable with the bank conceding that the award was void ab initio.

The above Delhi High Court ruling has shaken the trust in ad-hoc arbitration, and made financial institutions and borrowers question the neutrality of arbitrators, in general. However, there is a way forward – Independent Institutional Online Arbitration and Mediation, tried and tested at CADRE ODR over the last several years, with 60+ financial institutions referring disputes for institutional ODR.

Mechanics and legitimacy of institutional ODR

A loan agreement can name an independent ODR institution, agreed to by the lender and borrower before any dispute arises. When a dispute arises, the institution appoints an arbitrator from its panel under an established system-based algorithm. The parties have no say in the individual appointment, and fees are paid to the institution under a fixed schedule. Importantly, Institutional ODR also allows for parties to raise concerns about the process and grievances regarding the arbitrators at any stage of the proceedings, thus ensuring accountability and quality control of services provided.

In M/s Balaji Enterprises v. Sundaram Finance Ltd. (July 2025), the Delhi High Court upheld an award made through a mutually agreed institution. In D S Textiles v. IIFL Finance Ltd. (April 2026), the Bombay High Court recognised the importance of party consent in institutional appointments, distinguishing arrangements where both parties had agreed to the ODR institution from those where the institution or appointment mechanism was selected unilaterally by the lender.

Technology can address many of the procedural failures exposed in Shikha Ghosh. Cases can be allocated through pre-defined rules based on claim amount, seat, language and arbitrator workload. Arbitrators submit disclosures online before accepting a case. Both parties can review them and raise objections. Every notice, document and order are logged, so there is a record a court can examine if the award is challenged. Borrowers can access proceedings through all modes of digital system, follow proceedingsin their own language, view records and participate without having to travel around. Wellmanaged institutional proceedings can ordinarily be completed within 60 to 90 days.

While considering an ODR institution, lenders and borrowers should consider multiple factors, besides appointment of arbitrators. The expertise and training of the institutional arbitrator panel, their technological capabilities, market credibility, track record and empanelment with government bodies and regulators are some key factors. This is important to determine an institution’s ability to handle disputes efficiently and at scale.

The way forward – A multi-institutional ODR framework?

Loan agreements can name two or more independent ODR institutions operating under a common framework, with disputes allocated through objective, pre-agreed rules in line with the law. This spreads the caseload, provides a fallback and can accommodate portfolios ranging from ₹20,000 to ₹5 crore. This can bring greater choice, capacity and accountability to retail loan dispute resolution, and could be the next step in taking institutional ODR to scale.

Interestingly, there is also a surge in requests at CADRE ODR for online mediation and conciliation services. Online mediation allows banks and NBFCs to amicably resolve the disputes with clients within one or two weeks. Skilled mediators, a trusted tech-platform and a productive process flow is critical to a successful online mediation experience. Therefore, besides a multi-institutional ODR policy, an Online Med-Arb (Mediation-Arbitration) clause is a must for lenders and borrowers in an increasingly volatile financial market.

About the authors: Prabhakaran S is Chief Business Officer, Shubhangi Bhargava is Head of Public Policy and Advocacy, and Jonathan Rodrigues is Head of Mediation Services at CADRE ODR.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s). The opinions presented do not necessarily reflect the views of Bar & Bench.

If you would like your Deals, Columns, Press Releases to be published on Bar & Bench, please fill in the form available here.

Social media handle not licence to post anything: Karnataka High Court

DNLU, Jabalpur to host ‘JUSTECH’ National Conclave on the ‘Role of AI, Technology in Access to Justice’

Sanjeev Kumar Sharma joins White & Brief as National Head – Litigation & Dispute Resolution

Dr. Arvind Kapur, Rohan Yadav acquire minority stake in SeedWorks NeuVeg; Saraf and Partners, TLH Advocates advise

VERTICES PARTNERS advises Marico on ₹113 crore stake acquisition in Cosmix

SCROLL FOR NEXT