The Delhi High Court has quashed criminal defamation proceedings initiated against Senior Advocate and former Biju Janata Dal (BJD) Member of Parliament Pinaki Misra for calling a lawyer a “crook”.
In an order passed on November 17, Justice Sachin Datta observed that the complainant, advocate Siddhartha Singh, had failed to show that Misra's statement lowered his reputation in the estimation of others.
The Court allowed Misra' plea and set aside the summoning order passed by a trial court in April 2019 as well as the complaint filed by Singh.
"It is also noticed that the impugned order does not consider the context in which the words were allegedly used by the petitioner and the dismissal of the complaint by the Bar Council of Delhi," the Court said.
The case arose from an August 2018 report published by The Economic Times about a complaint filed by Singh before the Bar Council of Delhi, alleging professional misconduct by Misra over a conflict of interest.
At the time, Misra was a Lok Sabha MP and chairperson of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Urban Development.
Singh had objected to Misra appearing for power distribution companies before the National Green Tribunal, claiming that the committee chaired by him had made adverse recommendations against the companies.
The newspaper report quoted Misra as allegedly calling Singh a “crook”.
Singh then sent a legal notice to Misra seeking an unconditional apology before filing the criminal defamation complaint.
After considering the case, Justice Datta noted that Singh had examined only himself as a witness before the trial court and had not named or examined anyone who had read the report or whose estimation of him had been affected.
The Court also noted that the Bar Council had dismissed Singh's professional misconduct complaint in November 2018.
It further pointed out that a connected defamation case arising from a report published on Daily Hunt had already been quashed by the High Court in August 2026.
Senior Advocate Rebecca M John along with advocate Anushka Baruah appeared for Pinaki Misra.
Additional Public Prosecutor (APP) Aashneet Singh appeared for the State.
[Read Order]