Eladi Chewable Tablet | Eladi Candy 
News

Kerala High Court upholds injunction against candy maker over Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala's 'ELADI' mark

The Court upheld an interim injunction against Ameya sweets, after finding that the use of name 'ELADI' for their products was likely to confuse consumers familiar with Kadamkulathy Vaidyasala's products.

Praisy Thomas

The Kerala High Court recently upheld an interim injunction restraining Thrissur based Ameya Sweets from using the trademarks 'ELADI' and 'ELADI THRILL' for its candies after finding that the marks were deceptively similar to the registered 'ELADI' trademark of Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala. [Mrs Vineetha Suresh Babu & anr v Dr Rose Mary Wilson & ors]

A Division Bench of Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar VM on November 12, dismissed an appeal filed by Ameya Sweets and its proprietor Vineetha Suresh Babu, against an order of the Additional District Court, Thrissur.

The Court observed that Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala had established that the world 'ELADI' had become closely associated with its products through decades of use.

"Once the plaintiffs have prima facie been able to establish that the said word is closely associated with and identifiable with their products, and that an unwary purchaser with imperfect recollection would consider the said mark “ELADI” to be that of the plaintiffs, they are entitled to an order of injunction, unless the appellants/defendants are able to establish and offer a plausible ground or reason for adopting the said mark “ELADI” at a much subsequent point of time, as the law would not allow an infringer to thrive on the goodwill of the plaintiffs," the Court observed.

It explained that trademark infringement must be analysed from the perspective of an ordinary customer who may not remember every detail of a product's name or packaging.

Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar VM (Kerala HC)

The dispute arose after Dr. Rose Mary Wilson and KP Pathrose Vaidyan's Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala Private Limited (plaintiffs) approached the district court alleging trademark infringement and passing off by Ameya Sweets.

The plaintiffs claimed that their Ayurvedic chewable tablets marketed under the name 'ELADI' since 1989, had acquired considerable goodwill and recognition.

They alleged that Ameya Sweets had adopted a deceptively similar name and packaging to benefit from their established reputation.

In August 2026, the district Court restrained Ameya Sweets from using 'ELADI', 'ELADI THRILL', prompting them to approach the Court against the interim injunction.

Ameya argued that 'ELADI THRILL' was a separately registered trademark and that their confectionary products belonged to Class 30, whereas the Vaidyasala's medicinal products were registered under Class 5.

They also raised the contention that 'ELADI' was a descriptive term commonly used for Ayurvedic preparations and could not be exclusively associated with one manufacturer.

The Court, however, rejected these arguments and held that even a commonly used word could acquire a distinctive identity through long and extensive commercial use.

It further explained that prior use of a trademark could prevail over a later registration even if the competing products were registered in different classes.

The Court noted that 'ELADI' was prominently displayed on the appellant's products and that they had failed to provide a reasonable explanation for adopting the name.

It also referred to the principle of passing off, which protects a business against competitors misleading customers into believing that their products originate from it.

Thus, finding that the plaintiffs had established goodwill and that the rival mark was likely to mislead consumers and could harm their business interests, the Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the interim injunction.

Advocates K Radhakrishnan Nair, Sajen Thampan, Jinu Samyuktha Padmakumar, Ayoona PM, Athil Jamal, Ashmy Lal G and Sarika Krishna A appeared for Ameya sweets.

Advocates P Abraham Cherian, Nimmy K Joseph, Joe Joseph, Jaison S Rozario, Aravind Varghese, Pooja Jose, V Varun, Haritha Mohan and Amal John Sabu appeared for the Vaidyasala.

[Read Judgment]

Mrs Vineetha Suresh Babu & anr v Dr Rose Mary Wilson & ors.pdf
Preview

Maharashtra court staff temporarily suspend strike after Bombay High Court intervention

Take the writ to the district court: An alternative to regional Supreme Court benches

Foreigners accused of visa overstay can't be kept in detention centres after getting bail: Delhi High Court

Come to Delhi from Singapore only after AQI improves: Supreme Court's candid advice for litigant

Thiruparankundram lamp lighting: Dargah committee says Madras High Court judge inspected site before making them a party to case

SCROLL FOR NEXT