library (Picture for representation only) 
Litigation News

After row over case reassignments, Supreme Court Justice PV Sanjay Kumar refers Central Secretariat Library case to CJI

The Court had initiated a suo motu case over the lack of adequate arrangements for relocating the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) from Shastri Bhawan in New Delhi.

Ritu Yadav

A Supreme Court bench today withdrew from hearing a suo motu case initiated over the relocation of the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) from Shastri Bhawan.

A Bench of Justices PV Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva decided to recuse from the case in light of the recent decision by the Chief Justice of India (CJI) to reallocate PIL cases pending before benches which don't have jurisdiction to hear the same as per the court's roster.

The bench today said that though the office of CJI was intimated when the present matter was taken up by it, they do not have the roster for the subject matter. Accordingly, the Court referred the case to the CJI.

"Therefore, let the matter be placed before the CJI for listing before the appropriate bench," Justice Kumar said.

The Court made an indirect reference to the withdrawal of certain cases from a Bench headed by Ahsanuddin Amanullah.

The cases were purportedly withdrawn as that Bench had expanded the issues involved in them.

"Let's follow the procedure. You know what happened recently," Justice Kumar said.

The Bench added that the case may even come back to it but until the same is decided by the CJI, the bench will not hear it.

"It may come back to me in all probability but in the meanwhile you will have to stay your hands," Justice Kumar said.

Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva (supreme court judges)

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said the government has no objection to the Bench's decision to refer the matter to the CJI for further listing.

In the order passed today, the Court said,

"List matter before the Hon'ble Chief Justice on the administrative side for listing of this matter before appropriate bench."

The Court had initiated the suo motu case following a report published by The Indian Express highlighting concerns over the proposed relocation of the library from Shastri Bhawan amid the building's proposed demolition as part of the Central Vista redevelopment project.

Concerns had been flagged over the lack of adequate arrangements at the new site.

The library, which functions under the Union Ministry of Culture, was established as the Imperial Secretariat Library in Calcutta in 1891. It was subsequently shifted to Delhi and has been housed at Shastri Bhawan since 1969. It houses more than 8.5 lakh volumes, including rare books, government publications, official records and gazetteers.

Following the planned demolition of the building, the Culture Ministry had sought approximately 5,466 square metres for the library in the redeveloped Central Secretariat.

However, the Directorate of Estates under the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) proposed allotting only two rooms, measuring around 300 square metres at Kartavya Bhawan-2, for the library.

The Culture Ministry then informed MoHUA in February that the proposed space was inadequate to house the library's complete collection and facilities and that complete relocation to the allotted space was not feasible.

With concerns over the condition and future of books, the Supreme Court took suo motu cognisance of the issue after it was also flagged by certain retired judges.

On November 16, the Court had recorded the Centre's statement that the books would not be shifted before today's hearing on November 20. The Court had also remarked that the government needs to show some respect for the books.

Today, Solicitor General told the Court that his undertaking would continue till further developments in the case.

"My earlier statement continues. I had a word with the amicus. All of us will sit together along with the officers. We will find a way out," Mehta said.

Justice Kumar expressed concern over the condition of the books, stating that they must be taken care of. He added that the heritage is not limited to Lutyens’ bungalows.

"We are way more concerned about these books," the judge said.

Justice Kumar also referred to a fire incident in which books of a High Court library got burnt in 2009.

"Let me tell you, when we had a fire in the Hyderabad High Court in 2009, Justice Anil Ramesh Dave was the Chief Justice. The library burned down. Justice Subba Rao had literally fought with the Madras High Court to get hold of those books. All those books burned down in that fire. Chief Justice Anil Ramesh Dave cried. He had tears in his eyes."

[Read Live Coverage]

Supreme Court allows lighting of lamp at Thiruparankundram as one time measure but stays Madras High Court observations

Supreme Court allows bike taxis in Karnataka, rejects State's appeal to restore ban

Visually impaired Jammu & Kashmir High Court advocate on strike for appointment as law officer

Madras High Court agrees to hear Bangladesh’s challenge to India’s GI tag for Bengal's Tangail saree

Can't order takedown of other courts' orders from internet to protect privacy: Delhi High Court

SCROLL FOR NEXT