Chief Justice of India Surya Kant 
Litigation News

AI detectors incorrectly flag essays of non-native English speakers; students should not be penalised: CJI Surya Kant

CJI Kant also opposed a blanket ban on generative AI in legal education.

Ritu Yadav

Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant on Saturday said students should not be held guilty of academic misconduct solely on the basis of software that identifies their work as AI-generated.

He cited a 2023 study which found that seven widely used AI detectors incorrectly flagged more than three in five essays by non-native English speakers as machine-generated.

“In a Commonwealth where so many students write in English as a second or third language, an honest student could thus be branded a cheat on the strength of a number that no one can explain, and that student cannot meaningfully challenge. No student should therefore be held guilty of misconduct on the word of a machine alone,” he cautioned.

The Chief Justice was delivering the inaugural address at the Commonwealth Legal Education Association’s  (CLEA) first Annual International Conference on Legal Education in Hyderabad.

CJI Kant further went on to oppose a blanket ban on generative AI in legal education, calling it neither practical nor wise.

“A ban (on AI)  would only drive this use out of sight, where it can be neither guided nor examined. The wiser course is to set clear rules and to teach responsible use, so that technology assists the student’s search,” he explained.

Students should be told before an assessment which uses of AI are permitted, which require disclosure and which would mean handing over the thinking they are expected to do themselves, he added.

He also called for changes to how students are assessed.

“Assessment, too, must evolve, so that written work is supported by an oral explanation, a defence of the authorities relied upon, or an exercise in spotting the errors in a machine-generated answer,” the CJI suggested.

Turning to practical training, he warned against internship certificates issued without attendance and clinical grades awarded for work never done.

“An internship certificate issued to a student who never attended chambers, or a clinical grade awarded for work that was never done, fails not only that student but every client he or she will one day represent,” he remarked.

CJI Kant further proposed making a minimum period of legal aid work a condition for graduation.

“I would further suggest that a minimum period of legal aid work be made compulsory for every student to graduate, with additional credits for those who go beyond it,” he said.

Legal aid clinics should continue working during semester breaks and could also become centres of continuing education for practising lawyers, he added.

Delhi High Court quashes criminal defamation case against Senior Advocate Pinaki Misra

Women in high public office does not mean equality has been achieved: Justice BV Nagarathna at Oxford

Maharashtra withdraws its plea before Bombay High Court against FSSAI

Bengaluru court denies anticipatory bail to expelled Congress leader, others in Siddaramaiah sting video case

Calcutta High Court upholds murder charge against building promoter after collapse kills 15

SCROLL FOR NEXT