The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday upheld the death penalty of a man found guilty of raping and subsequently murdering his neighbour's five- year-old daughter after luring her with chocolates [State of West Bengal v. Ashok Singh].
A Bench of Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray noted that the convict Ashok Singh raped the child through her vagina as well as anus and later killed the child by inflicting injuries on her head.
His actions could plainly be classified into the "rarest of rare" category, thus fitting the criteria to attract a death sentence, the Court ruled.
"The manner of raping a 5 years 10 months old child through her vagina and also her anus were sufficient to take the life of the child but to ensure her total collapse he banged her head against hard substance. In my view, the death of the victim was done with extreme depravity and this brutal nature of rape and murder of the 5 years 10 months old child, is in my view, qualifies as one of the rarest of the rare cases," the judgment said.
The Court was hearing an appeal preferred by Ashok Singh challenging an order of a trial court which had sentenced him to death.
The crime took place on November 24, 2024 when the victim's father noted that the girl, who had gone out to visit a neighbour's home, did not return even after a substantial amount of time had passed.
Subsequently, when the neighbour told her mother that she had left her home several hours back, a search party comprising local people set out to find her, ultimately discovering her at Singh's home, unconscious, naked, and bleeding. She was subsequently taken to a hospital where she was declared dead.
Several witnesses were examined, one of whom said that she saw Singh approaching the girl when she was returning from the neighbour's home and asked her to accompany him to his home under the pretext of giving her chocolates. However, since they were all of the same locality, and the victim addressed him as "jethu" (uncle), the witness did not sense anything amiss.
Singh, however, denied all the allegations levelled against him and said he did not know how the victim's body ended up at his home.
A forensic report later revealed Singh's DNA all over the victim's body parts.
The trial court found him guilty of offence of raping a child under twelve, aggravated sexual assault and murder. The Court found that the convict had tracked the victim's movements and calculated the timing of the act to avoid eye witnesses.
The trial court concluded that the case fell into the category of 'rarest of rare', and imposed death penalty on Singh.
He then approached the High Court.
Advocate Amit Ranjan Pati, appearing for Singh argued that the entire case was supported by circumstantial evidence.
Since there were no eye witnesses to the crime, the "last-seen" theory, meaning the fact that the victim was last seen with Singh, was not a conclusive proof of his guilt, it was contended.
He also submitted that there was no proof that Singh was the only person present in his home at the time the crime took place and hence, placing the entire burden on Singh in the absence of cogent proof risked chances of Singh's false implication.
Special Public Prosecutor Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee rebutted these arguments. He emphasised that the statements of all the witnesses corroborated each other's and that Singh could give no proper explanation of how the victim's body ended up at his home. He also placed reliance on the forensic report that showed the presence of Singh's DNA on the victim's body parts.
The High Court considered the possibility of alternative punishment for Singh before settling on a death penalty. It weighed the statements given by witness doctors and forensic experts in the matter who noted that Singh was completely lucid, aware and did not suffer from any mental or emotional illnesses. The Court also took note of the fact that Singh was mentally sound and did not show any remorse when it came to giving statements to defend his cause.
He had given the false impression that he did not commit the offence although his semen was found in the private parts of the victim, the Court further noted.
"This attitude shows that for the purpose of his defence he could pretend that he is innocent," the Court observed.
It was also brought to the Court's notice that Singh was under suspicion of inappropriately touching another five-year-old girl. Hence, the Court ultimately concluded that Singh was beyond reformation.
While confirming Singh's death penalty, the Court directed a three month stay on the operation of the death penalty order in case he decides to approach the Supreme Court.
The Court was also unimpressed by the State's failure to award the parents victim compensation issued a directive ordering it to award the parents an enhanced compensation of ₹15 lakh within two months.
The matter will be heard again on January 30, 2027 to monitor compliance with the order.
Advocates Amit Ranjan Pati, Swastika Chowdhury, Ilika Nag, Yavik Singhal, and Avijit Chatterjee represented Ashok Singh.
The State was represented by Special Public Prosecutor Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee along with advocates Santanu Talukdar, Moumita Pandit, Supreme Naskar, and Ritushree Banerjee.
Senior Advocate Kaushik Gupta and advocate Apalak Basu appointed by the Calcutta High Court Legal Services Committee also appeared.
[Read Judgment]