The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission at Panchkula recently penalised Reliance Retail Limited and Reliance Smart Superstore for diverting ₹1 of a ₹19 refund into a customer’s Twid reward wallet without her consent [Nishtha Raghav vs Reliance Smart Superstore & Reliance Retail Limited].
The Coram of President Satpal and Members Dr Sushma Garg and Dr Suman Singh held that the unilateral wallet adjustment amounted to a deceptive "dark pattern" and deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
Hence, it held the opposite parties jointly and severally liable and directed them to pay ₹2,500 as lump-sum compensation to the complainant and ₹5,000 as punitive damages to the Free Legal Aid State Commission at Haryana within 45 days.
The complaint was filed by Panchkula resident Nishtha Raghav, who placed two grocery orders on the JioMart application on January 23 and January 25, 2026. On both occasions, a Munch Max chocolate bar priced at ₹19 was unavailable.
While JioMart notified her that a ₹19 refund had been initiated to her original payment mode for each order, only ₹18 was credited to her bank account. The remaining ₹1 from each transaction was transferred to her Twid (Pay with Rewards) wallet without prior disclosure or authorisation.
After her in-app grievance was closed without relief and a February 14 legal notice went unanswered, Raghav approached the Commission under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
Despite entering appearance through counsel, the opposite parties failed to file their written statement despite multiple opportunities, prompting the Commission to strike off their defence on June 26.
After examining the unrebutted documentary evidence on merits, the Commission observed that while product unavailability by itself is not a deficiency in service, a bank account and a reward wallet are distinct modes of holding monetary value.
"A consumer cannot be compelled to accept wallet credit in place of a refund to the original mode of payment, particularly when the opposite parties had represented that the amount would be refunded through the original payment mode," the order stated.
Crucially, the Commission flagged the practice as a deceptive dark pattern under the Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023.
It noted that retaining part of a refund inside a digital reward ecosystem without informed consent manipulates consumer choice by nudging users to undertake repeat transactions on the platform to utilise the credit.
The repetition of the practice across two orders ruled out an inadvertent accounting error, the Commission said.
Hence, it invoked the proviso to Section 39(1)(d) of the Act to impose punitive damages alongside compensation for harassment and litigation expenses.
Advocate Parmod Bhardwaj appeared for the complainant.
Advocate Rahul Goyal had appeared for the defendant.
[Read Judgment]