Do fee-free guarantees for group company loans attract GST? Delhi High Court answers

The High Court took a view contrary to a Bombay High Court ruling and in line with a verdict delivered by the Gujarat High Court.
GST, Delhi High Court
GST, Delhi High Court
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

The Delhi High Court on Tuesday held that a company’s guarantee for a group firm’s loan attracts Goods and Services Tax (GST) even if the company charges no fee for it [Sterlite Power Vs UOI].

The High Court took a view contrary to a Bombay High Court ruling and in line with a verdict delivered by the Gujarat High Court. The Bombay High Court had held that such guarantees fall outside the GST net.

A Division Bench of Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Bharat Parashar said the Bombay High Court’s ruling in DP Jain & Co. Infrastructure relied on a Supreme Court decision under the earlier service tax regime, where the payment formed part of the definition of a service.

“The service lies in the assumption of the risk of the related person’s default, and the resulting extension of the guarantor’s creditworthiness to it,” the Bench said.

Justice Anil Kshetrapal
Justice Anil Kshetrapal

The judgment was passed on a batch of petitions filed by Sterlite Power Transmission, ReNew, Jindal Stainless, Azure Power, Essar Power, GAIL and others.

The companies argued that a parent company gives a guarantee to protect its investment in a subsidiary and that such a guarantee given without a fee falls outside the GST net.

The High Court set aside the challenged notices, orders and demands to the extent they conflicted with its ruling. It directed tax officers to hear the companies and determine their liability afresh.

In DP Jain, the Bombay High Court’s Nagpur Bench had considered three guarantees that a highway developer gave between 2020 and 2022 to secure bank loans for group companies.

The deeds provided for no fee, commission or other consideration. However, the Bombay High Court held that the guarantees were enforceable by the lenders on default and that, without consideration, they did not constitute a taxable supply.

However, the Delhi High Court said that Bombay High Court had relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Edelweiss Financial Services, which arose under an earlier law that made consideration part of the definition of a service.

The Bench said the Bombay High Court did not appear to have examined the combined effect of Section 7(1)(c) and Entry 2 of Schedule I of the Central GST Act. Those provisions cover supplies between related parties in the course or furtherance of business even without consideration.

The High Court agreed with the Gujarat High Court's finding in Torrent Power that such guarantees attract GST. The Court held that the service is complete when the guarantor assumes the risk by executing the guarantee. However, the Court also said that GST does not arise afresh each year merely because the guarantee remains in force.

The Court read down Rule 28(2), holding that treating 1 percent of the guaranteed amount per year as a compulsory minimum violates Article 14 of the Constitution.

The Bench held that Rule 28(2) applies to guarantees executed, renewed, extended or increased from October 26, 2023. Guarantees issued between July 1, 2017 and October 25, 2023 are taxable under the valuation rules then in force, the Court added.

Senior Advocate Balbir Singh appeared for Sterlite Power and its co-petitioners.

Senior Advocate Sujit Ghosh appeared for ReNew and Azure Power.

Senior Advocate Balbir Singh
Senior Advocate Balbir Singh
Sujit Ghosh
Sujit GhoshLinkedin

Additional Solicitor General N Venkataraman appeared for the respondents in several petitions.

Additional Solicitor Genera N Venkataraman
Additional Solicitor Genera N Venkataraman

Pertinently, the Supreme Court had on November 16 issued notice on petitions challenging the Gujarat ruling and stayed the disputed GST demands until further orders.

[Read Judgment]

Attachment
PDF
Sterlite Vs UOI
Preview
Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com