Paranjoy Guha Thakurta Facebook
Litigation News

Gag on reporting about Indiabulls: Delhi High Court leaves matter to trial court, closes Paranjoy Guha’s appeal

The Court noted that a similar appeal by Delhi Press Patra Prakashan was disposed of on November 4, by directing the trial court to examine the matter.

Bhavini Srivastava

The Delhi High Court today directed a trial court to expeditiously examine whether an ad interim ex-parte order restraining various media outlets and journalists, including Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, from reporting on Indiabulls and its promoter, Sameer Gehlaut should continue.

Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri issued the directive while disposing of an appeal filed by Paranjoy Guha Thakurta.

Thakurta had challenged the ex-parte trial court directing the takedown of a 2019 article concerning Indiabulls and its promoter, Sameer Gehlaut, and restraining any further reports on the subject.

Today, the Court noted that a similar appeal filed by Delhi Press Patra Prakashan (publisher or Caravan magazine, among others) was disposed of on November 4, by directing the trial court to examine the matter.

Justice Ohri also noted that the interim order being challenged is listed for further consideration before trial court on November 21.

The Court, therefore, closed Thakurta's appeal as well after directing the trial court to decide the matter expeditiously.

"Today it is informed that the (interim injunction) application (filed by Indiabulls as part of a defamation suit) is listed for further consideration on November 21. All defendants (Thakurta and others) have been duly informed of the hearing. Subject to the appearance of all the defendants, the trial court shall ensure expeditious disposal of the application. The present appeal is disposed of," the High Court ordered.

Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri

Guha's plea challenged an October 24 interim order passed by a trial court in a defamation case.

By this order, the trial court had directed takedown of a 2019 article titled ‘The Maze of Political Links of Indiabull’s Sameer Gehlaut’, co-authored by Guha and published on NewsClick in 2019 and on Guha's website as well.

The trial court order also restrained any further publishing of articles and content regarding Indiabulls.

Guha challenged this directive, contending that such a blanket restraint on all future reporting is an unconstitutional form of prior restraint. Guha argued that the trial court's order comprises vague and overbroad restrictions on free speech. Among other grounds, he has also contended that Indiabulls suppressed material facts to obtain the injunction order. The plea was filed through advocates Deeksha Dwivedi and Fahad Khan.

However, Senior advocate Rajiv Nayar, appearing for Indiabulls and Gehlaut, today told the Court that a similar appeal was recently disposed of by the High Court on November 4.

Senior Advocate Rajiv Nayar

In the November 4 order, the Court had also noted that the interim injunction application is yet to be finally decided. Therefore, the High Court directed the trial court to given its decision on the interim injunction application within three weeks.

Today, the Court noted that the matter is slated to be heard next by the trial court on November 21, and directed that the trial court give its decision on the interim injunction application expeditiously.

With this direction, Thakurta's appeal was also disposed of.

[Read live coverage]

Attorney General grants consent for contempt of court case against lawyer over remarks against CJI Surya Kant

Is Delhi High Court biting off more than it can chew? [WATCH VIDEO]

Caste discrimination at temple dedicated to Ramanuja extremely unfortunate: Madras High Court

Renewable energy in India: From capacity expansion to energy transition

Private universities audit case in Supreme Court shifted from Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah Bench

SCROLL FOR NEXT