Private universities audit case in Supreme Court shifted from Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah Bench

While hearing the matter, Justice Amanullah had ordered sweeping financial disclosures and a crackdown on fake colleges across India.
Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah
Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

In an unusual administrative move, a part-heard Supreme Court case concerning a nationwide audit of private universities has been reassigned from a Bench led by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah to a newly constituted three-judge Bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath [Ayesha Jain v. Amity University Noida & Ors].

According to the Supreme Court's case status, the case, which had been regularly heard as a part-heard matter by Justices Amanullah and NV Anjaria until October, will now come up on November 19 before a Bench comprising Justices Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh.

No reasons have been disclosed on the judicial record for the sudden change of bench just days ahead of the scheduled hearing.

Justice Vikram Nath, Justice R Mahadevan and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh
Justice Vikram Nath, Justice R Mahadevan and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh

The development is particularly notable given how aggressively the previous ench had expanded and monitored the present proceedings over the past year.

The case originally began in mid-2025 as an individual grievance filed by 23-year-old student Ayesha Jain against Amity University, Noida. Jain alleged that University officials harassed her, barred her from classes and caused her to lose an academic year after she legally changed her name from Khushi Jain to Ayesha Jain.

While the Bench pulled up Amity's top officials over their treatment of the student, it refused to close the matter after granting her relief. Instead, in November 2025, Justice Amanullah's Bench expanded the scope of the petition in the larger public interest to scrutinise how private universities across India are established, funded and regulated.

Over the course of multiple hearings, the Bench issued a string of far-reaching directives:

  • Highest-level accountability: In November 2025, the Court ordered the Cabinet Secretary of India, Chief Secretaries of all States and Union Territories, and the University Grants Commission (UGC) Chairman to personally affirm affidavits detailing land allotments, statutory relaxations and governing body structures of private universities. When the Union government filed an affidavit through the Higher Education Secretary instead, Justice Amanullah took strong exception, remarking that the Court had shown "magnanimity" by not summoning the Cabinet Secretary to court.

  • Ban on profiteering: On September 17 this year, the Bench ruled that private universities cannot be run as commercial, profit-making ventures. It directed all States to collect five years of audited accounts from private institutions, along with granular disclosures on fee structures, surplus fund usage, faculty recruitment, actual classes conducted and student grievance redressal.

  • Crackdown on fake colleges: Most recently, on October 9, the Bench acted on an application flagging a fake medical college operating out of a dilapidated farmhouse in Uttar Pradesh's Etah district with an illiterate tea-seller listed as its chairman. Taking note of the police action and a Chief Secretary-ordered inquiry, the Court directed the UGC and all regulatory bodies to issue public advisories warning students to verify institutions before seeking admission.

In the same October 9 order, the Bench also dealt with a sealed cover report submitted by Dr RM Sharma - who had been nominated by the Court to assist in the matter - regarding the progress of a Child Safety Monitoring Committee originally constituted by the Delhi High Court before the issue was transferred to the apex court.

After examining the sealed cover communication, the Bench refrained from reproducing its contents in the order, but authorised Dr Sharma to reconstitute the committee with four additional members alongside the Chairman, before ordering the report to be resealed and kept on record.

At the conclusion of that October 9 hearing, the Bench headed by Justice Amanullah had directed the matter to be listed next on November 19 at 2 PM.

However, with the fresh roster allocation, the expansive probe into private higher education across the country will now be taken up afresh by a three-judge Bench led by Justice Vikram Nath.

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com