Yamuna Pollution Manish Swarup/AP Photo
Litigation News

Poor health of Yamuna reflects everything wrong with civic administration: Supreme Court

The Court said that despite huge public money being spent on cleaning the Yamuna, pollution has only increased over the years.

Ritwik Choudhury

The Supreme Court recently observed that the deteriorating condition of the Yamuna river mirrors the failures of civic administration along its banks [NOIDA v. State of UP & Ors.].

A Bench of Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan noted that pollution in the Yamuna continues to worsen despite massive public expenditure.

"Everything that is wrong with civic administration in the towns, cities and villages situated along the banks of the river is reflected in the poor health of the river and in the 520 drains that discharge wastewater into the Yamuna. This is why, despite huge sums being spent on cleaning the river, pollution in the Yamuna has only increased," the Court said.

It invoked the doctrine of Common but Differentiated Responsibilities (CBDR) to hold States and Union Territories accountable if water quality degrades within their borders.

"If the water quality deteriorates on any parameter while flowing through, or exiting a State/Union Territory or a District therein, then that State/Union Territory or District within the State/Union Territory shall be held accountable and penalised," the Court warned.

Justice Manmohan and Justice Manoj Misra

To ensure existing pollution treatment infrastructure runs at full capacity, the Court issued a slew of technological and enforcement mandates:

  • Smart Meters and Sensors: Every Sewage Treatment Plant (STP), Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP), and government biogas plant must install tamper-proof smart energy meters and continuous inflow-outflow sensors within one month, with live readings uploaded online. Any data break exceeding 24 hours will be presumed as non-operation.

  • Surprise Audits: The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) will conduct unannounced quarterly sampling of all STPs of 5 MLD capacity and above through IITs, NITs, or accredited labs, recovering daily environmental compensation from non-compliant operators.

  • GPS for Septage Tankers: Urban local bodies must register all septage tankers, equip them with GPS tracking, and launch a dedicated portal to monitor household waste collection and disposal.

  • Officer Accountability: The officer in charge of every treatment plant and major drain must be named on the public portal and file monthly compliance affidavits before the Court.

The Bench was hearing a batch of civil appeals concerning the rejuvenation of the river, in which a committee headed by the Union Home Secretary had submitted a draft 'Yamuna Action Plan.'

The Court noted that the plan was a step forward in identifying domestic sewage as the primary pollutant. However, it also flagged glaring contradictions in the draft plan.

It highlighted that while the plan claimed water bodies and wetlands in Delhi's Zone 'O' were free of encroachments, an annexure prepared by the Delhi government marked all 35 water bodies in the zone as encroached. Similarly, despite claims that 28 of Delhi's 37 Sewage Treatment Plants (STPs) met applicable standards, a CPCB report showed none met all prescribed norms.

Among other corrective directions, the Court has now also directed the CPCB to collect water samples at entry and exit points of every State and district, get them independently verified by institutes like IITs, and suggest a formula for levying fines on polluters.

States will be at liberty to recover these penalties from polluters and errant officials.

The Bench further stressed that unauthorised colonies, slum clusters, and illegal dairies along drains and riverbeds must be removed after rehabilitating occupants, noting that laying sewage networks in unplanned settlements is nearly impossible.

It also ordered that Zone 'O' in Delhi be strictly protected as a green zone with no permanent structures allowed, and called for extending this green buffer from the Yamuna's source to its confluence with the Ganga so the river has space to meander.

The Court further directed Chief Secretaries of all Yamuna basin States and concerned Central Ministries to nominate a Special Secretary-rank Nodal Officer within two weeks to coordinate with the CPCB.

The matter has been listed next on January 13, 2027.

The Court's order was passed on November 4. 

Less than two weeks later, during the Chhath Puja celebrations between November 13 and 16, widespread visuals emerged from Delhi showing devotees wading into thick layers of toxic white foam floating on the Yamuna to perform rituals, sparking renewed political and public outrage over the river's condition.

[Read Order]

NOIDA v. State of UP & Ors..pdf
Preview

Journalist Paranjoy Guha moves Delhi High Court challenging gag order on reporting about Indiabulls

Were grounds of arrest served on Azam Khan before his arrest? Allahabad High Court asks ED to file affidavit

Rahul Gandhi moves Supreme Court to serve 48 interrogatories on Election Commission over SIR

He arrives in Mercedes-Benz and lectures me on judicial duties: Madras High Court Justice GR Swaminathan on communist MP

"Show these books some respect": Supreme Court questions 'ad-hoc' shift of 135-year Central Secretariat Library

SCROLL FOR NEXT