

Madras High Court Justice GR Swaminathan on Monday criticised Communist Party of India (Marxist) MP Su Venkatesan for advising him on how to discharge his judicial duties, while questioning the parliamentarian's lifestyle, including his use of a high-end Mercedes-Benz car and branded clothing.
The judge made the remarks while hearing a contempt petition concerning alleged irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu.
Justice Swaminathan said that Venkatesan, who represents Madurai in the Lok Sabha, had criticised his recent remarks suggesting that books on spirituality be placed in the Periyar Library to atone for the alleged fraudulent procurement of books.
Recalling an encounter with the MP at Chennai railway station about six months ago, the judge said,
"He claims to be a communist leader, you know? But he comes in a high-end Benz car, wears branded everything and I don't know whether the book royalties will sustain such a lifestyle."
Justice Swaminathan said that he had seen a Mercedes-Benz car outside the station while preparing to board the Pandian Express from Chennai to Madurai. He initially assumed that the person alighting from the vehicle was a corporate executive because of his branded clothing and shoes, before recognising Venkatesan emerging from the car.
The judge said that the two walked towards the train together. While Venkatesan was travelling in First AC, Justice Swaminathan was proceeding to the Sleeper Class compartment.
"He said, 'Sir, Judge sir, where are you going?' I said, 'I normally travel by Sleeper Class. My number is S3-23.'"
Referring to the MP's subsequent criticism, Justice Swaminathan remarked,
"So this...he is telling me as to what I should do as a judge."
The remarks came after Venkatesan criticised Justice Swaminathan's comments at a book release function concerning the alleged procurement of fraudulent books for the Periyar Arivulagam Library in Coimbatore.
At the function, the judge had suggested that books on Maha Periyava, the late Kanchi Shankaracharya, be placed on the shelves where books supplied by Agal Vilakku Publications had been stocked, as a means of atoning for the alleged wrongdoing.
Responding on X on November 15, Venkatesan said that the alleged irregularities constituted corruption and that those responsible ought to be punished according to law. He argued that punishing corruption was the responsibility of judges, whereas prescribing atonement for sins was the work of astrologers.
The MP also invoked BR Ambedkar and Periyar, saying that they were remembered for their contributions to legal thought and rationalism, respectively.
During Monday's hearing, Justice Swaminathan clarified that his earlier remarks were intended as a joke.
"I just cracked a joke, okay? It was really meant to be a joke only."
He explained that his suggestion to replace the books with works on spirituality had been made in a lighter vein.
"By buying these books and stacking the racks, they have committed a sin. Let them wipe away that sin by replacing them with books on spirituality."
Meanwhile, State Public Prosecutor John Sathyan informed the Tamil Nadu government informed the Court that the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) had registered an FIR in connection with the alleged fraudulent procurement of books for public libraries.
The State further disclosed that Agal Vilakku Pathippagam proprietor Mohan had been named as an accused in the FIR. It added that five officials had been suspended and that searches were being conducted at seven locations.
The Bench, which also comprised Justice MD Sumathi, was informed that approximately ₹20 crore had been disbursed out of ₹30 crore sanctioned for the procurement exercise.
Advocate General Vijay Narayan assured the Court that the investigation would cover everyone involved, irrespective of their position.
"No person who was involved in this will go unpunished. That Your Lordship can be assured."
The Court recorded the assurance and indicated that it intended to conclude the contempt proceedings within one or two more hearings, leaving the investigation to the competent authorities.
The matter was posted for further hearing on November 20.