The Supreme Court on Monday laid down five safeguards governing the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal’s (NCLAT) power to send approved resolution plans of companies under insolvency back to the Committee of Creditors (CoC) for reconsideration [Twinstar Technologies Limited v. Bank of Maharashtra & Ors.].
A Bench of Justices PS Narasimha and Alok Aradhe held that such remand must rest on a finding of legal non-compliance, advance the objectives of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) and carry strict directions to follow statutory timelines.
“The power of remand must, therefore, be exercised in a manner that secures its benefit by incurring the least potential costs,” the Court said.
The ruling came while dismissing Twinstar Technologies Limited’s appeals against NCLAT’s decision to set aside approval of its resolution plan for Videocon Industries Limited and twelve other group companies.
The dispute arose from Twinstar’s resolution plan for Videocon Industries and its group companies. The plan, involving a financial outlay of approximately ₹2,962 crore, secured approval from creditors holding 95.09 percent of the voting share in December 2020.
It provided for ₹2,700 crore in non-convertible debentures carrying an annual coupon of 6.65 percent, with redemption spread over instalments extending to the sixth year.
The NCLT approved the plan in June 2021 but directed that dissenting financial creditors receive their liquidation entitlement in cash upfront, before payments to assenting financial creditors.
Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI and SIDBI challenged the approval. In January 2022, NCLAT set aside the approval of the resolution plan and returned the matter to the CoC.
Before the Supreme Court, Twinstar argued that NCLAT lacked the power to remit the plan and that the CoC could not revisit its approval.
The Court rejected these arguments. It held that neither NCLT nor NCLAT could rewrite a resolution plan or substitute its own commercial judgment for that of creditors.
Where a defect required changes to the plan’s commercial terms, the appropriate course was to return it to the CoC.
The Court explained that setting aside a defective plan without remand could push a company towards liquidation where the insolvency resolution period had already expired.
However, remand also carried costs, including prolonged litigation, uncertainty, increased financial burdens and depletion of asset value. Therefore, its exercise require safeguards, the Court said.
Thus, the Court prescribed the following five safeguards:
Advance the IBC’s objectives: Remand must further the objectives of keeping the corporate debtor a going concern, ensuring fair and reasonable recovery for all classes of creditors and maximising asset value during insolvency resolution.
Identify legal non-compliance: Remand must rest on a finding that the plan fails to meet the mandatory requirements under Section 30(2) of the IBC, including payment of insolvency costs, minimum payments to operational and dissenting financial creditors, and provisions for management and implementation, or contravenes any law in force, a ground for appeal under Section 61(3)(i).
Exercise the power sparingly: NCLAT must act with circumspection, without departing from express statutory procedures or exceeding the limits governing inherent and implied powers.
Remand to correct improper modifications by NCLT: Where the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) modifies a plan to cure a defect instead of returning it to the CoC, the NCLAT may remand it to restore their respective statutory roles.
Enforce statutory timelines: Every remand order must carry strict directions to follow the timelines under the IBC and relevant regulations, so that the remedy does not itself cause further delay.
The Court also refused to restrict reconsideration to Twinstar’s existing plan. It said that it is upto the CoC to decide in its commercial wisdom whether to consider a modified plan or invite fresh bids.
It accordingly dismissed Twinstar’s appeals and upheld the remand.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta appeared for the Committee of Creditors.
Additional Solicitor General N Venkataraman appeared for Bank of Maharashtra and Bharat PetroResources Limited. Additional Solicitor General Vikramjit Banerjee represented the Union of India.
Senior Advocate Guru Krishna Kumar appeared for Twinstar Technologies.
Senior Advocates KK Venugopal and Gopal Sankaranarayanan represented Venugopal Dhoot.
Senior Advocate Maninder Singh appeared for the VIL Vendors Association;
Senior Advocate Nakul Dewan for Pertamina;
Senior Advocate Niranjan Reddy for the resolution professional of Videocon Industries.
Senior Advocate Shashank Garg appeared for GAIL (India) Limited.