Supreme Court of India 
Litigation News

Supreme Court questions homebuyers approaching it directly over builder disputes

"Under Article 32, how many such matters are we going to resolve?" the Court asked.

Debayan Roy

The Supreme Court on Thursday questioned why homebuyers were approaching it directly invoking Article 32 of the Constitution to resolve disputes arising out of failed housing projects, instead of pursuing their remedies before lower courts.

A Bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana said it cannot be expected to deal with every dispute between homebuyers and builders.

“Please appreciate, under Article 32 (allowing litigants to approach Supreme Court directly for relief when fundamental rights are violated), how many such matters are we going to resolve? Every dispute against a builder, every failed project, will end up here. How are we going to resolve it?” CJI Kant remarked during the hearing.

Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana

The Court made the observation while hearing a plea by homebuyers over a stalled Sonipat housing project, seeking protection from recovery proceedings initiated by the State Bank of India (SBI).

The Court, however, ultimately issued directions to protect the homebuyers from any coercive recovery by SBI.

It directed the commercial court to first examine whether the bank had released loans to the builder in accordance with their agreement and whether the homebuyers were actually in default.

The petitioners (homebuyers) had approached the Supreme Court seeking protection from coercive proceedings to recover loans taken to purchase flats in the Krishna Housing Scheme in Sector 14, Sonipat.

Their counsel told the Court that the homebuyers had entered into a tripartite arrangement with the builder and SBI to finance under-construction flats. Under the arrangement, the bank was required to release loan amounts in stages linked to the progress of construction.

However, the builder allegedly failed to fulfil its obligations and the project did not get completed. The developer has since been admitted into insolvency proceedings before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT).

The petitioners' counsel submitted that the homebuyers had neither received possession of their flats nor the refunds promised under the insolvency proceedings.

Despite this, SBI had initiated recovery proceedings against them before the Commercial Court at Saket in Delhi.

Before the top court, the petitioners sought a stay on the recovery proceedings and requested that their plea be tagged with another pending petition concerning loans given to builders.

Taking note of the submissions, CJI Kant questioned why the homebuyers could not raise their objections before the commercial court, where the recovery suits were already pending.

“You have filed a commercial suit? It is pending before the civil court. Raise all your objections there,” he said.

The counsel responded that the homebuyers had already raised their objections before the commercial court, but recovery proceedings were continuing. He added that the builder had failed to release the six monthly instalments of refund promised during the NCLT proceedings.

CJI Kant then said the Supreme Court could direct the commercial court to consider the homebuyers' objections before proceeding with recovery.

In its order, the Court noted that the bank appeared to have disbursed the loan amount to the builder despite there being no corresponding progress in construction.

The Court held that the commercial court must first examine the arrangement between the bank and the builder.

“In our considered opinion, it is the duty of the court first to determine the nexus between the builder and the bank authorities and to see whether the bank disbursed the loan amount to the builder strictly in terms of the tripartite agreement,” said the Court.

It directed the commercial court not to take coercive action against the homebuyers unless it first examines whether they were actually in default.

[Read Live Coverage]

Madhya Pradesh High Court slams State for citing fictitious case law generated by AI tool

Retired Justice Rajesh Bindal takes charge as NCLAT Chairperson

Ariyil Shukoor murder: Kerala High Court acquits CPI(M) leader P Jayarajan and 17 others, convicts 13

Karnataka High Court quashes case against man who posted that Siddaramaiah will distribute nation's wealth to Muslims

Delhi High Court stays Lokpal proceedings against Defence Secretary Rajesh Kumar Singh on corruption complaint

SCROLL FOR NEXT